Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

I'm facing a dilemma, either move to the Midwest to try and find employment, or stick it out here in Utah?

My story is kind of a long, annoying one, so thanks in advance for bearing with me! LoL!!! I moved to Utah in 2004 to go to college, which was somewhat successful. I got an Associates Degree, which doesn't mean much, I know. I then transferred to a 4-year school here in Utah to attempt to get a Bachelor's Degree, and after changing my major several times, and running out of federal financial aid, that didn't happen.

I'm 31 and have been on Social Security Disability since 2003, and haven't really worked much since then either, but as I said above, have been going to school off and on during that time. I am on SSDI (Social Security) due to depression and anxiety problems, which have really improved tremendously in the last 9 years!

As I said, my options for financial aid for obtaining a Bachelor's degree have run out, so I'm not even considering that option. One option I have been considering is getting a job as a CNA (Certified Nurse's Assistant). It's something I've very familiar with, as many of my family members have done it in the past or currently do it now as a job. I get it's nothing glamorous, but I'm not looking for anything glamorous, just a job that pays decent (I'm not picky, minimum wage is decent for me even), has benefits, and is relatively secure, which in some parts of the country, is a CNA job. CNA jobs also seem to be in plenty demand in various areas like the Midwest, and don't seem to be going anywhere any time soon with America's aging population. Yes, I get there's other jobs that pay better, have better conditions, I know. I've been thinking about a CNA job in a Nursing home, as that is what I'm most familiar with (from family member's employment experiences). I've always got along and worked well with the elderly, and I know and am prepared for the good, the bad, and downright messy aspects of the job. I've applied for CNA jobs here and there over the years, but due to school at the time, or anxiety, further back, I didn't end up taking the jobs when I was offered them. As I said, those things are not a problem for me now.

Here's where my dilemma starts. I've really been considering moving to Nebraska, North Dakota, or South Dakota, or other nearby states as they have very low unemployment rates and plenty of CNA jobs, and most other jobs, available. I realize unemployment rates don't mean everything too, but they are a plus for the Midwest. Here in Utah, we have CNA jobs, of course, but they seem to be harder to get, with large waiting lists just to get into CNA training programs. I also am fully aware, that, due to my lack of recent work history, I'm not going to be on the top of the list when employers are looking through applications. I'd rather apply for a job where 2 or 3 people are applying for it, rather than 20 or 30, then I honestly may as well not bother. I'm not trying to be pessimistic, just realistic! I think this is where I'd have an advantage in the Midwest.

Currently, I'm doing relatively well, but everything I have is from various social services. My income, my health insurance, etc. I'm also near the top of the waiting list in my city for Section 8 housing assistance through HUD. I'm grateful to receive all these benefits, and I'm not looking for criticism of me or the programs, because I do qualify for them and am not "using the system," but I feel I'm to a point in my life where I can do more. I can either stay here in Utah, where unemployment is not terrible, but it's not great either, and lower-education jobs like CNAs often pay less than in the Midwest, and often don't have the benefits that they do in the Midwest (I've done plenty of research on this). Here in Utah, I can coast by, but probably not find work, and probably remain on government programs. I'm not ashamed to be on these programs, but would like to be a contributing member of society and not be on them, plus I believe that working and being productive would make me feel better overall, regardless of the field. Rather than stay here and wait for things to "get better" and maybe get a job down the line, I could go to Nebraska or a Dakota, where I think I may have better chances with my current situation. I am from the Midwest (Iowa) originally, and I believe I have the mindset and values of a Midwestern person, and understand and relate to the people there. Utah's nice and all, but after a while, especially if government programs get cut, I might not be doing so well. What's the point of beautiful mountain scenery if you have no money or means to enjoy it, after all.

I'm really leaning toward this Nebraska (or Dakota) plan to become productive and get off social programs. There's people who need them now more than I do. Any ideas or input on my situation would be much appreciated!

My family li

Update:

- looks like my last sentence got cut off, I was just saying my family lives in Iowa & Nebraska. That's more of a happy coincidence in my choice to move there, not a large contributing factor!

5 Answers

Relevance
  • 9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Another vote for North Dakota. We're hurting all over. You wouldn't have to go to the oil patch (housing is nonexistent AND expensive there right now). You could try either the cities (relatively speaking -- Fargo, Grand Forks, Bismarck, Minot) or the nonstagnant towns, like Jamestown, Valley City. Or smaller but stable and in need of employees -- Carrington, Harvey, Cooperstown, Hillsboro, Wahpeton, Casselton, Steele, etc. CNA's make far more than minimum wage here, I believe, and they don't worry about out-of-town applications as much. They need help.

    It's a good starting point to get where you may want to be in a few years, especially if you decide to pursue more higher education.

    Glad you are doing so much better -- now may be the perfect time to make a positive change in your life. Good luck!

  • 9 years ago

    I also agree that you should try to find a job before you commit to moving. Can you take a short vacation to stay with family and try to look for a job while you're there?

    Also, understand that CNA jobs are not really going to provide you with a financially stable life. It's not likely you will be able to afford your own apartment, vehicle, food, insurance, and all your other monthly expenses on that wage unless you're working straight night shifts and working overtime. CNA is not really a long-term viable career. I hope you're considering doing something else in the long run, like going on to get your RN. If you already started working towards a bachelor's you might only be 2-3 years from being able to complete a BSN. Otherwise you could just go for an ADN program at a community college. Either way, if you got your RN license you'd be set for life, earning 3-4 times the wages of a CNA.

    Source(s): RN in the midwest
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    It's great that you are considering options before just up and moving. I would caution you about moving before you have a job. It's expensive, depressing and stressful to basically start over anywhere.

    Consider find companies that is hiring there and apply online. You will be competiting and it is more difficult long distance. But competition won't end just because you live down the road. \

    Use the college career center. They may offer resume writing, interview skills, job search seminars - take advantage of everything. Some companies recruit at colleges so you will be in a familiar environment.

    Volunteer - if you aren't already, find a place to volunteer while you are job hunting. This will refresh your skills and give you something new to put on a resume.

    Discuss your employment options with a Social Security counselor. You may be limited what you can work at while on SSI, and they will be able to discuss your options.

    Engage your family to discuss their help. Since they already live in one of the areas you are considering, they will know the industry hiring practices.

    Good luck...

  • ?
    Lv 7
    9 years ago

    North Dakota is booming now. That would be my recommendation. You are young enough to make a career and be successful and make contributions to social security. If you dont return to work you will end up at age 68 with the same amount of social security as you get now to live on. You would not have anxiety and depression if you straightened yourself out. Dont take medications. Eat heatlhy and exercise and dont smoke. You will be ok.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 7 years ago

    Utah land of the mormons and tithing I mean morons

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.