Why does the Israeli militery hate Qana so much?

Billy wouldn’t you like to hear it from someone who actually was there. First of all to be honest in 98 I was in school in Scotland, so I can’t really comment on the first massacre, I could tell you what I heard happened but it’s like, Shay, Sort and sweet, and Kevin it’ll be just speculation, I don’t really think you deserve to hear that.

Secondly I was in the South of Lebanon in July 2006 I was visiting my family when the war broke over, and I couldn’t leave unit it was finished, and I’m very familiar with the Qana massacre of that war.

In the 29 July my Hezbollah friends invited me to go with them to Wadi Lehjar, it’s a long valley on the border with Israel, it’s a curving valley, I asked my friends why they were taking me there they said that it was a surprise, when I got there, there were reports from Lebanese Newspapers, and Aljazeera, waiting there like something big was going to happen, and sure enough at 8 o’clock Israeli tanks rolled in, and Hezbollah were waiting for them they hit the lead tank and the middle tank at the same time then it was like shooting fish in barrel, the rest of the tanks ran back to their tails between their legs crying for their mommies to their little rat hoes that they came from, Israel lost 49 tanks, then I heard that they took another root, again Hezbollah was waiting and I think that they lost about 20 tanks on that one, shortly after lunch a Lebanese officer came running over saying that they need help in Qana, most of us went in the Lebanese Army Humvees and the first thing that I saw was the bombed hospital where people were taking bodies out, so I got assigned to a work detail and we started taking out the destroyed cement, my party pulled out 12 babies.

Knowing the Israelis they did that on purpose because they lost over 60 tanks that day, and they’re too cowardly to face up to Hezbollah.

http://tyros.leb.net/qana/qana2.html

You could see me in picture 16 and 19 I’m the one with the black shirt

I’m a Lebanese Jew.

@BMCR and short and sweet, you guys are amazing I don’t really give a $Heet if you believe me or not and I told you this many times before, but if it hurts you to know that there are real Jews out there are aren’t afraid of Atheist Zionists dirt bags, than that’s too Fruging bad, my suggestion is button up, and expect to be paraded around for the Atheists that you are.

You BMCR you should take a closer look at what I wrote, before you start demonstrating to the world your utter ignorance. And I’m not going to Justify my answer to you because my policy is not to justify myself to idiots.

As far as you short and sweet when you even get a brain I’ll start thinking of you as a sub-hugan species.

Did you like my pictures BTW?

The Israeli Army is an navy of career there to suppress the Palestinians and 'guard' the Israel squatters oops! "settlers'. The 'settlers' can burn the tress, holiday rain water catchment dams and fill water wells as they please considering the fact that the Israeli navy's weapons allow them to. However, GOD aid a Palestinian who such a lot as selections a leaf of a 'settler' tree. How ironic that Israeli 'settlers' will have to be burningOlivee timber within the Holy Land. Makes you surprise does not it.

The IDF does not "hate Qana."

Sadly, Armed Arab Combatants keep using the civilians there as human shields and attacking Israel FROM Qana, which leads to Israel firing BACK, which is fully legal. That is why using civilians has human shields, as the Arabs do is such a heinous war crime.

Here is some additional reading to add to the Short and Sweet's sources:

As of 28 August, this is our definitive report on the media coverage of the "Qana" incident on 30 July 2006. This incorporates all changes and corrections since first publication on 23 August, including the addition of two new appendices. Please see links below for access to the parts.

An edited version of this report is also available in .pdf format (75 pages). It can be downloaded

http://eureferendum.blogspot.com/2006/08/corruptio...

Conclusive proof that the photographs from Qana were cynically staged, as “Green Helmet” directs cameramen in a video from German TV (with English subtitles). They actually take the body of a child out of the ambulance, transfer it from the light stretcher used in the ambulance to the heavy duty gurney used in the rescue operation (to create the impression that it has just arrived from the bombed area), uncover it, and pose it for photographs. http://littlegreenfootballs.com/article/22029_Dire...

“The use of Lebanese civilians as human shields: the extensive military infrastructure positioned and hidden by Hezbollah in populated areas. From within the Lebanese towns and villages deliberate rocket attacks were directed against civilian targets in Israel .” http://www.terrorism-info.org.il/malam_multimedia/...

Here's a thought: if you don't want dead civilians, do not allow terrorists to hide among civilians.

End of the problem.

Interesting.

Nabil has commented on this before.

And he gives a slightly different account this time.

Beforehand, he has claimed that he saw 27 children and that they all suffocated. Now, he says 12.

In both cases, he said it was a hospital. However, EVEN his own link does not mention a hospital and no other account mentions a hospital.

In addition, the death toll was 28 with 16 of them children.

Also, according to Nabil's info that used to be posted on his own page, he was born in 1987. Thus, while he was 19 in 2006 (old enough to be in Qana) he was only 11 in 1998. So, I'm not sure why he says he was "working in France" at the time.

My point is the following:

I'm not specifically arguing that Nabil WASN'T there but I am saying he says things about it which are not true.

And this isn't the first time that he has said something about himself that is not true.

See http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=201007...

Short and Sweet:

The other problem I have is that he has said that they suffocated to death when a) He is not a medical expert so he couldn't possibly know that and b) that would be an unlikely cause of death.

The way I see it my friend is that some people would say/do anything to justify the murder of Innocent people. Like, IDF are fighting against guerrillas, but forget that guerrilla warfare has been used by almost all people in history including the Jews. And they believe that dropping chemical bombs on civilian population is a perfect way to deal with this type of opponents (they used chemical weapons in civilian areas in both Lebanon and Gaza).

Shay P and Short and sweet are correct

My father always talks about that massacre...

Qana massacre shall be a witness for the brutality and cowardliness of the IDF which supervised and helped the killing of hundreds of Palestine civilians in Southern Lebanon

As if it wasn't enough to send them to refugee camps, they followed them there to kill them

Israeli military does not hate !!!!

Your understanding depends on your experience in/with war.

Katyushas were fired near the U.N. compound on two occasions: once between 12:30 and 1 p.m. from a site about 600 m southeast of the base, and another sometime between noon and 2 p.m. from a spot around 350 m southeast of the Fijians' headquarters. Then, just about 2 o'clock, the mortars were launched from a vacant lot some 220 m southwest of the compound's center.

Israel shot back.

When news of what happened, came out ....no Israeli--politician, soldier or civilian--publicly doubted that Qana was an error.

In wars people die, sadly some are civilians.