Can an agnostic be a saved Christian?

You cannot be agnostic (by definition) and a Christian at the same time.

Christ said that the top two most important commandants were to love the Lord with all your "heart" (which you said) soul MIND (which is the thing in question) and strength. and the second is to love your neighbor as yourself.

I'm trying to wrap my mind around this, idea of "knowing" God without "Knowing about God". I don't think it's possible because you need to know that Jesus died for your sins and trust in His sacrifice in order to be a Christian.

If the alternative were true (if I'm reading you right) Christian's wouldn't need to evangelize about Christ.

Is that what you were looking for?

-----------

Oh! I almost forgot your second question. To love God with all your heart is to love Him with all your passions. This puts Him as a desired (not necessarily successful at first but it can happen or else Jesus wouldn't have said it, but only through the Holy Spirit) uppermost desire. This isn't an obligation anymore but something you want with your everything. It's intense!

Didymus

________

Response

The problem here is that if the person in question is truly believing in Christ then He would know that He is the only way (Jesus said that, but I don't remember where, I can google it if you want).

I don't know if your bud is going to heaven or hell. Unfortunately we can't know his heart. God does- but from what I can tell his foundation isn't very stable right now.

I could shake His faith pretty easy with a few questions and he could denounce God if He doesn't know it to be true. Your friend is missing out on the attributes as things are. He will be tossed around like the waves of the sea. How can He make disciples when He himself doesn't know the Bible to be 100% true? If claims to say that He does know that then He has to accept what I said earlier thus making your friend not agnostic.

Sure, you can believe in the Christian mythos while acknowledging that none of it is actually demonstrable. Religious agnosticism is reflected by statements such as, "God works in mysterious ways", "You cannot know the mind of God", or "You have to have faith". All are acknowledgments that "God" is not something for which you can present evidence. It is something that people believe more for emotional reasons than logical ones. An unfounded belief or unprovable belief is still a belief.

Religion is superstition, but that does not stop people from believing it.

YES, I guess they could be saved...BUT. I do have to correct you... An Agnostics is one who DOUBTS the existence of god, it has nothing to do with... WHAT is known about God. There is a lot KNOWN about God, Agnostics want PROOF of God. So with that being said... It would depend on the individual and what proof they found for themselves, that would make them believe.

You have to believe in the divinity of Jesus to be a Christian.

Not really. Agnostics say we can't possibly know one way or the other. Christians are supposed to "know" with every fibre of their being.

no cuz when he is saved he will say he is a Christian.

No