Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Should driving a manual transmission be a requirement for obtaining a driver's license in the USA?

The only correct answer is, "Yes". Barring some sort of medical condition, requiring new drivers to learn and take their driving tests in a manual transmission has many benefits:

1) Decreased decreased driving. You can't talk or text while you're shifting. You have to pay attention to what's going on with the car. Automatics have made driving so boring and numb that your natural tendency is to think about other things you can do with your time instead of driving. Automatics facilitate distracted driving.

2) Increased automobile awareness. People who know how to operate a manual transmission have a better understanding of how a car operates. Drivers today are becoming so removed from the driving experience that they're basically a passenger in their own vehicle.

3) Better fuel economy.

4) More vehicle operation flexibility. If your teen is out at a party and their driver, who happens to be driving a stick, gets drunk, your responsible kid can safely driver their car home.

Basically, if you are too uncoordinated to drive a manual transmission equipped vehicle, you should not be driving in the first place. Placing this requirement as a mandatory hurdle to cross will greatly increase driver awareness and skill-set. It's time we get serious about driving in the USA.

Update:

Dimo J has the title of the most ignorant post thus far. Keep your comments coming everyone. This is entertaining.

Update 2:

Oh, and computers magically make a hydraulically driven automatic more efficient than a direct drive manual? LMAO! Some people just have no clue about how cars work. LOL!

Update 3:

Some more information for people. Here's a news article about the growing trend of making new teen drivers learn to drive manuals: http://www.news10.net/greathangup/article/173814/3...

Update 4:

Information for people about fuel economy. Manual transmissions resulted in 2 to 5 MORE mpg's than an automatic (not a dual clutch or CVT): http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/cars/new-cars/n...

Update 5:

Test of manual vs automatic transmission. The result? Manuals used 10% less fuel on average. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KWa6Is2XkLA

6 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    yes

  • 9 years ago

    Don't bash those you don't know. You asked for opinions and got a VERY informed one.

    I believe the ability to drive a manual should be required.

    Today's manuals have parts inside that make them differ from the true manuals of the past. You slide a lever without thought, and it goes into gear.

    People with manuals don't really know much more about their vehicles - I could point to many examples I know personally.

    Today's automatics are more efficient with today's drivers. The automatic has become better and the driver worse.

    For what it's worth, I have often drank a cup of coffee, smoked a cigarette, and yakked on the CB all while driving a "manual" in city traffic. So much for not being able to do things.

    As I said, I prefer a manual - it is to my taste, I like the interaction.

    I also believe that true safety lies with the operator, not the equipment. Therefor, the automatic is not to be blamed for lousy drivers and thier habits. That lies elsewhere.

    If the ignorant and lazy were taught properly and followed the teaching......

    But, the majority want "easier" whether it be ease of use or "do it for me".

    Personally, I think being required to pass a test on basic walking (according to the rules and regulations) before even being allowed to enroll in Driver's Ed would be a damn fine first step.

  • 9 years ago

    While I do enjoy driving a manual transmission, I feel the answer is no!

    1. Learning a stick should be reserved for drivers who have mastered basic driving skills. The beginners attention has too much to cope with and sensory overload takes place.

    2. The place to learn automobile awareness should take place on a closed driving course where the student is encouraged to learn the limits of a cars handling. Where obstacles can be placed in the way to teach accident avoidance or it could be soaked to present the problems of standing water on the road.

    3. Better fuel economy is not a guaranteed thing.

    4. Teens should not be allowed to go to parties where the designated driver gets drunk.

    Yes, there needs to be a better method of training drivers both old and young. But IMHO requiring drivers to be able to drive a manual transmission does not accomplish the task.

  • Dimo J
    Lv 7
    9 years ago

    You are wrong. For safety, manual transmissions should be banned.

    Manual transmission cars are used by those who want to drive faster, having more collisions.

    Manual transmission have would working on the car instead of watching the road.

    You are a wrong, you can talk or texting while driving a manual car -- quite easily.

    You are wrong, automatic transmissions have better economy.

    *You* are too uncoordinated to drive a manual transmission correctly -- that is why you have a synchronized transmission instead of a crash box. You do not double clutch and you do not toe and heel.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ?
    Lv 7
    9 years ago

    How often do you shift? You really think that people can't drive and text still? Sorry but that's not going to happen. There is NO WAY to get people to stop it. As to fuel economy that isn't the case anymore. The computers in vehicles have taken care of that.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    9 years ago

    no.

    think of the stupid people who text and drive or eat/drink whatever.

    it's just the other hand off the wheel.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.