Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
dog breed dna testing?
I know it is probably not the best use of money, but we've been considering ordering a DNA test for a couple of our mixed breed dogs. So far I've heard of Wisdom panel and Canine heritage. Does anyone know of other companies that offer this and what are your opinions about the companies? What is the best one to go with in your opinion? How accurate do you feel they are? On the form that you have to fill out, what kind of information do you have to provide? I mean I don't want to tell them I think he looks like a standard poodle/ aussie mix and this is what he looks like. I want to make sure there is no bias or cheating. ;) Also, do you know of any deals for testing multiple dogs? We have six and all except for one is a mixed breed so it would be awesome to find a great deal for multi-dog owners and test them all.
Thanks for the answers so far and trust me they are well loved whatever breed they are. Knowing wouldn't change a thing it would simply satisfy curiosity...that is if it was somewhat accurate.
4 Answers
- 4Her4LifeLv 79 years agoFavorite Answer
There is "bias" and no "cheating" - the test will tell you which genetic markers the dog has which match the markers of dogs sampled from various pure breeds... but that doesn't necessarily actually tell you anything about the dog's actual pedigree.
For example: Bloodhounds were cross-bred with Bassets to save the breed after the World Wars, ALL of the Retriever breeds have common ancestry or were crossed until about 100-150 years ago, almost all breeds were developed from other breeds and those markers may still be there even though the dog carrying them is a Manchester Terrier and not a Whippet (and ancestor of Manchesters) for example.
The test also does not have information on all breeds or all lines within a breed - there is a great video on youtube of a purebred, AKC Champion American Staffordshire Terrier, while some argue that the test "doesn't test for AmStaff" I would have expected it to come back with some kind of related breed instead of a Border Collie as the best match! The test did indicate both Bulldog and Boston Terrier, which are related to AmStaff, but it would be asinine to think that there was ANY Border Collie in the last 200+ years of that dog's pedigree!
Thus, the test can be fun, but cannot actually accurately indicate the actual breeds in a mix.
- Anonymous5 years ago
DNA trying out to figure out your dogs breed is a rip-off. A vet I used to work for began providing it to his customers (a part of why I left) although he KNEW it was not accurate (but would make him alot of cash). Plus what do you do if the experiment says your canine is a component whatever it is not - argue? Finding out principally what breed your dog is won't alternate whatever - you will still love your canine the same - correct? Except you just like the inspiration of jogging around telling individuals, "Oh she's not a mutt - she's 30% German Shepherd, 30% Doberman, and forty% Beagle." AKA A Mutt.
- ladystangLv 79 years ago
to me they are a waste of money and just used for fun
have heard of people testing purebreds that showed up mixes
\just ask your vet or love the dogs as they are.
- Anonymous9 years ago
ALL ARE PROVEN ***SCAMS***!!!!!!!
You have unknown & unguessable mutts-get over it.