Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

If god exists he can't control existence. Would you agree?

He created laws for how the universe works and he doesn't seem to have to follow them. In many cases for something to break such laws you would assume it would create catastrophic results for anything following the laws in close vicinity. I think he would have to recreate the universe every time he wanted to personally change something. So it seems the best way for god to control the universe would be......not to exist :D Which is...well...not very possible.

Obviously I can't back this up with the my limited knowledge but I just want to know what you think.

Update:

Actually it would be more correct to say "I just want to know how you're going to disagree and tell me my logic is flawed this time"

Update 2:

@thedevilisinthedetail: I'm not suggesting it's true at all. It's just a thought. If I had evidence I'd probably be a famous scientist and not wasting my time on R&S where people like you have more facts than imagintation. Ideas come first, trying them out comes after.

5 Answers

Relevance
  • 9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    interesting idea. which would explain a bit why god does not seem to intervene in our lives. hence why logically he doesn't exist. but that's pretty convoluted i think. lol.

  • 9 years ago

    “Earth is a school for learning duality and understanding “opposites,” which helps you fast track your spiritual growth. Reincarnation and freewill are the tools for this spiritual growth. For every fantastic lifetime of love, joy, and happiness, there has been an equally strong and negative emotional experience of devastation, hardship, pain, and suffering.

    There are no such things as hell, the devil or satan; these are false manmade beliefs, which were created for explaining the unloving attributes of pain, suffering, chaos, and destruction created by early civilizations (infant souls). As souls, each one of you has had many different lifetimes on Earth. Before each incarnational cycle, you decide what lessons you want to learn, the basic requirements for your life and the type of polarized experiences you want to explore on Earth.

    Reincarnation helps you master your lessons in duality. You have been killed and killed by others; you have been male and female, including mother, father, son, uncle, grandmother etc. You have been a soldier, warrior, villain, farmer, and artist. You have experienced suffering, disease, illness, poverty, pain, joy, love, freedom, and fear. To learn from all the possible lessons of duality that has been possible on Earth, you have experienced every different human aspect available on the planet. Today, many souls have now come to the end of their study of duality. Many of you have nothing more left to learn on Earth.

    The major purpose of reincarnation is learning and also clearing “uncompleted” life lessons from previous lifetimes. After you master your lessons, you do not need to repeat them again. The number of experiences or reincarnated lives is completely a matter of choice for each soul. Some souls may experience hundreds of incarnations while others may master the same lesson in five incarnations.

    Before you incarnate from the spirit world, a group of spiritual advisors helps you decide the lessons you need to experience in this lifetime. Between incarnations, all souls return to the “Spirit World”. Your spiritual advisors are known as your “Council of Elders”. The Council review and refine your spiritual lessons for your incarnation. This is known as your “Incarnational Contract,” which serves the purpose for each incarnation. Your contract also includes the need to teach and/or learn from other individual/s or groups of souls, thus you establish mutual contracts with others.

    Situations and events are created to bring souls together to learn these lessons. Once the soul contract is finalized, you then select the secondary aspects such as the time and place of your birth, your parents, siblings, sexuality, health status, pets etc and then you finally incarnate into the body during gestation to begin a new incarnation. When you are born, you have amnesia (known as the Veil of Forgetfulness). You start your new life without any recollection of previous incarnations or lessons you have to master in this lifetime.

    Each spiritual being has a different spiritual path. There is no right or wrong. Every good and bad experience gets you one step closer to perfection. Compassion means that no person has the right to judge another person’s decisions, choices, and wrongdoings, because you do not know what the spiritual lessons and/or karma those souls are here to experience.

    Your spiritual development is dependent on your ability to consciously evaluate each human experience, understand lessons, accept the consequences of your actions and overcome your weaknesses, until you perfect your lessons. Else you will have to repeat the same script in your next lifetime.”

    http://cosmicawareness.org/Ascension-Study-Guide.p...

  • 9 years ago

    Since Quantum Theory, scientists have decided that laws of physics are mere guidelines. They are statistical. So God can do whatever he wants and not break any law of physics.

  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    Thats possibly the weakest argument I have read in some time.

    We rely on facts to support our premise.

    Please use them.

    Even I could simply say that God is all powerful and is able to change things at will and control the outcome. Thats why he is all powerful.

    Source(s): Atheist
  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    god can't control anything. if she can, then god can only control the weather, and if this weather goes about killing people, then god doesn't control the weather any more.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.