Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 6
? asked in SportsOutdoor RecreationHunting · 8 years ago

To all the Pheasant hunters out there what is your preferred shot shell?

I have been using the Prairie Storm 3" #4, with a full choke in 12 gauge for a few years now with great results but I am curious what everyone else is using and having good results with.

The main reason I am asking is because my parents moved to Jamestown ND and now the only place to get ammo when I go home on leave is at the local walmart. So instead I plan on ordering online and having it sent to their house. It is a lot easier than to buy it in AZ and fly home with it. Last year all they had were some Remington 2 3/4 #4 and #5. It worked but didn't perform near as well.

Update:

Really dca. Where have you ever seen where 7 1/2 is suggested for pheasants. I have never seen it or head of it, and I have been hunting pheasants for 17 years. I use that size for dove and quail. Not pheasants. That load doesn't have the penetration or power to be used for pheasants. The smallest I have ever used for pheasants is #5. Especially the birds up in North Dakota. There feathers are really thick up there due to the cold. During late season 7 1/2 would just tickle them.

Update 2:

The only reason I get on you dca is because of how stuck up you sounded. "The correct and proper". There is no correct or proper size. It is all based on personal preference and needs. Also it isn't uncommon for shots to be out to 50+yards during the later season. We hunt behind flushing dogs. I forgot to mention that.

Update 3:

No I wont yell. The only problem with wild birds is they tend to get up wild. 40 and 50 yard shots are common out there. I would say the average is probably 30 to 35. That is why we use full chokes and big shot. Usually if we hit them they are done. We don't get very many wounded birds in our group. I have used 6 once and had more wounded birds than I care to admit. I just can't bring myself to trust something so small. Also I don't like chasing wounded birds. I would rather get a quick clean kill and maybe ruin the meat vs loosing a bird. Either way you don't get the meat but I can sleep better knowing the bird isn't out there suffering. That is just me and how I look at it.

Update 4:

Yeah. I am one of those plan for the worst people. I usually only shoot at birds at that distance when it has already been hit. If it gets up at 50 yards I don't shoot. Mainly because by the time you get your gun up and everything the bird is already at 60 yards. Our average is around 30 to 35. That is the problem, usually if someone hits it at 35 now by the time you register this and know to try to shoot again it is farther. Also when we hunt with a group a lot of times birds will get up and be closer to one person than the other. Well when the first person hits it and needs help taking the bird down it is nice to be able to take them down. Usually the bird is again only 35 yards from one person but 50 yards from the next. It is more of a cautionary thing. I can't remember how many people I have helped out finishing off their birds for them. Of course we are making sure the angle is safe and were not putting anyone at risk.

5 Answers

Relevance
  • 8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    I was in SD last fall for pheasant and we used 3" winchester #2 steel with great success. I have used #5 lead in the past but we hunted some wetland areas this year and I didn't want to worry about switching ammo.

  • 8 years ago

    i also like #6's or #7 1/2's i really like 7 1/2's in a high brass shell when i can get them loaded. the smaller shot is better at slipping between feathers instead of having to punch through them. their skin is so thin and they have almost no fat, so the 7 1/2's do great when they slip past the feathers. the 7 1/2's are also less likely to penetrate through to the breast and ruin the meat as most pheasants are shot from behind. i have never used a 3 inch lead shell for pheasant, only in steel when it was required.

    for me personally, a 50 yd shot is a little unethical, even with dogs, you are taking a big chance of wounding the bird and it gliding for a mile before it hits the ground and dies. but dont yell at me, thats just my opinion.

    EDIT: if its successful for you, then do your thing. nobody likes that crappy feeling of losing a bird, kinda spoils the mood. do what you have to in order to avoid that feeling. i rarely shoot wild flushed birds. but i usually have a pointer with me too. in my experience, it only makes my dogs less cautious and they start working farther from the gun. if the weather is terrible, that can be a good thing, but on a mild day when the birds are apt to fly, it makes for wild flushes at 50 yards. just a little different method of hunting them i guess. i flush most of the pheasant that i bag. if i dont flush them, then the lab or springer is doing it right in front of me. that kind of close, steady work can corral birds to small areas where they are easier to put the dogs on. just more of a finesse method maybe. so it requires a little more finesse in shotshell choice.

    i just dont like taking 50 yard shots. at that distance, you can wound it and not even know it. i have seen birds get their feet shot off and fly over the horizon. i really dont know anyone who thinks 50 yards is in range for flushing pheasant. im not taking jabs, im just saying, you are the only person i have ever heard of that plans for 50 yard shots. everybody i know lets those fly off, or blocks the other end of the field. or they work slowly to allow the birds to walk to a corner. but they dont shoot at 50 yards

    Source(s): 25 years of pheasant hunting over pointers and flushers
  • 8 years ago

    * The proper and correct size bird-shot for Hunting Pheasant is number 7-1/2 size bird-shot.* I prefer the Winchester Brand Double AA's in number 7-1/2 size bird-shot.* You Sir are badly and sadly mistaken if you use #4, #5, or #6 shot for hunting pheasant.* Experienced Pheasant Hunter for over 60 years.*

    Source(s): * Run like a Deer.*................Fly like an Eagle.*~~
  • 8 years ago

    Early on in the season i'll use #6 later on #5. Either Express or Eley.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Mr.357
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    6 Maximum 12 ga.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.