Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Chop off your hand?! Was Jesus Serious?!?
“If your right eye causes you to sin, gouge it out and throw it away. It is better for you to lose one part of your body than for your whole body to be thrown into hell. And if your right hand causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away. It is better for you to lose one part of your body than for your whole body to go into hell.” (Mt 5:29-30)
Bible Puzzle #1. :)
(well if you saw my previous questions i deleted them, this would make the first)
@Come fly with me.. lol
@woo k, you check and answer again :)
@Steven, Skunky and Just saying, well no comment for now, my comment would be the answer to the puzzle :)
@gregory, nope. it's not a metaphor. :)
It is inconceivable that He would play with words for the crude purpose of ramming home a lesson. When Jesus spoke in parables He did so to conceal truths, not to stretch them (Mt 13:13). In any case, the passage above is not part of a parable. The context is the Sermon on the Mount and Jesus has just been speaking about anger and lust. His language is plain because the issues are serious. There is nothing metaphorical about His choice of words.
Preachers sometimes exaggerate to make a point but Jesus always meant what He said and said what He meant. He is Truth personified.
=====answer to the puzzle=====
He’s preaching law on steroids not so that you will try to keep it but so that you will give up pretending you are.
If you’re broken and hurting you’ll get grace, but if you’re self-righteous and religious you’ll get law. A self-righteous person is one who thinks he can impress God with his religious performance. The only language he understands is law. He says, “all these commands I have kept from my youth, what else do I lack?” And Jesus responds, “Okay, you asked for it, here it is – receive some more law.”
The law is not a standard to live up to, but a mirror that reveals our faults. The law was not given to help you overcome sin, but to help sin overcome you (Rms 7:8-9). In the Sermon on the Mount Jesus was preaching to people who thought they would be judged righteous if they kept the law. But instead of being silenced by their inability to do so, they had watered it down making it easier to keep.
In Matthew 23 Jesus gives some specific example
of how the Pharisees had diluted the law, but in Matthew 5 He sets about raising the standard of the law to its proper level. In other words, He was polishing the mirror.
Why did Jesus do this? Why did our gracious king spend so much time preaching the law? Because some people will never appreciate the good news until they’ve heard the bad news, which is this:
“Unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven.” (Mt 5:20)
The law is holy, righteous and good, but try to live by it and it will condemn and kill you (2 Cor 3:6,9). The purpose of the law is to bring man to the end of himself and reveal his need for a Savior (Gal 3:24). If you are self-righteous, you will never appreciate Jesus until the law has done its job and plowed the pride out of your smug little heart. I’m a decent person, you say. I’ve never killed or committed adultery. Not good enough, says Jesus. God knows your heart. If you
If you’ve entertained murderous or lustful thoughts you’ve as good as done it. You’re in danger of hell-fire. This is a serious business, says Jesus. If you persist in this pathetic course of self-reliance, you had better be prepared to go the whole way even if that means sacrificing an eye and a hand
And knowing there would be some religious wackos out there who might miss the point and actually go to such extremes, Jesus hits them with this:
“Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect.” (Mt 5:48)
God expects perfection and nothing less. If you’re not perfect, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, you’re in serious trouble. Now here’s the good news:
“Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them.” (Mt 5:17)
Jesus fulfilled all of the requirements of the law on your behalf. You are not perfect, but thank God you have a perfect high priest!
“Therefore he is able to save completely those who come to God
“Therefore he is able to save completely those who come to God through him, because he always lives to intercede for them. Such a high priest meets our need—one who is holy, blameless, pure, set apart from sinners, exalted above the heavens.” (Heb 7:25-26)
Jesus was born under the law and fulfilled the law to redeem those under the law so that we might receive the full rights of sons (Gal 4:4-5). Because of what Jesus has done we are no longer under the law but the grace of God (Rms 6:5). The good news is that His righteousness far surpasses the righteousness of the Pharisees and He offers it to you as a free gift (Rm 1:17).
13 Answers
- 4allpupsLv 68 years ago
I have always maintained that IF 'Jesus' did actually exist, he was the olden day version of some drug fu..ked bludger that went around spinning stories in exchange for food, clothing and shelter! Just a story teller with a terrific imagination that spun a 'story' to suit the peoples of wherever he happened to be at the time!
One day it is 'An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth', the next it is 'Turn the other cheek'!
This entire fiction - irrespective of race, creed, colour and religion - is just that. Fiction. The entire Bible contradicts itself constantly. Then hundreds of years ago, when blind idiotic followers started wising up, they introduced the different testaments etc. etc. etc. Because by then, some smart and greedy people jumped on the bandwagon and saw a way to make money out of this 'story teller'.
It kept growing and the world ended up with multiple religions - all with one common theme - some 'almighty creator'. Now the world is totally f...d up because of this crap! The Catholics and the Muslims being the major players - two ancient families and their descendants - still fighting for the big bucks in these books of fables!
Personally, I hold more stock in the stories of Grimm, Aesop, Roald Dahl, Stephen King and Enid Blyton etc. etc. etc!
- RobinLv 78 years ago
Jesus taught us in stories... some were very graphic and used very clear images. This was a serious point and He used strong words. He wanted people to take sin seriously and the daily struggle to keep ourselves on the right path as being so important.
Interesting He also used the body and body parts to describe the christian family or church and when the early church came across major arguments that threatened to break it apart the apostles used the same strong language.
Now think back to the famously wise King Solomon who said cut the baby in half... did he really want that to happen? No, of course not , he knew the real mother would rather give up her child than see if murdered.
- 8 years ago
‘Cut off your hand.’ Jesus spoke of ‘cutting off one’s hand,’ not literally but in a figurative sense, when he said: “If, then, your hand or your foot is making you stumble, cut it off and throw it away from you.” He meant that, instead of letting a body member such as a hand or a foot cause its owner to commit unforgivable sin, he should deaden such body member as completely as if it were severed from the body.—Mt 18:8; Mr 9:45; compare Col 3:5.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- \\\Lv 58 years ago
This was metaphorical. Yes, it is better for you to enter heaven with one hand than to go into hell. There is a very specific message He is trying to convey. Is cutting off your hand going to make you stop sinning? No. What do you do, cut off your other hand? Gouge out your eyes? You will still be a sinner, right? What is required to make you stop sinning? It is a heart issue. In order to stop sinning, you have to stop your sinful heart. A death must be required. Here's the good news: He died for us so that we don't have to. So yes, it's better to enter heaven with one hand and one eye than to go to hell. But the Bible also commands us not to self-mutilate because your body is a temple to the Holy Spirit. So die to your sin, and live for Him. He nailed our sin to the cross (Galatians).
- Just SayingLv 58 years ago
Most of his preachings were just repeated from the Old Testament. The few original ideas he came up with were repulsive.
- Anonymous8 years ago
Yes. He is trying to say, "Look dude, Hell is some real nasty stuff! Trust me. You DON'T want to be there. In fact, if you were in Hell you'd be saying, 'Man, I wish I would have cut may hand off than be here!'"
- 8 years ago
It's not a TOTALLY bad piece of advice. If you had cancer or MRSA in your hand, wouldn't you get rid of it rather than die from the spread of the disease?
- GregoryLv 78 years ago
it was a metaphor jesus was using in teaching
he did not mean literally cut it off