Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

? asked in SportsMartial Arts · 8 years ago

can you get a black belt in martial arts on your own?

ive been training independently for years now. not sure the act age i picked it up but its long enough ive forgotten. ive also spent past 6 years training in throwing weapons and small arms. how ever no a days no one gives a damn if you can hit 5 separate targets, 50 yards a way, blind folded, while eating an apple and solving a rubix cube with your feet(exaggeration) unless you have that black band around your waist. with out a black belt i cant pursue more advanced training that i can come up with on my own. no im not that kid who watches $1 kung fu movies and thinks he can do it too. i actually have invested alot in training equipment, books, legitimate instuctional videso and watched countless demonstrations. i just haven't actually gone through a class at the local ymca so to speak. so give the information can i just purchase a belt online (do so knowing i deserve it) or must i actually go through "official" training rather than credit on private training.

p[s: list of requirements for black belts in Japanese style martial arts would be appreciated

Update:

so many interesting replys. alot of you were never taught humility and not to boast. guys really? its the internet. all i wanted was to know if there's way to train independently (private instruction) and be tested by some federation under the specific style of an individuals choosing. and if you can get a categorized black belt for knife throwing or sword fighting. the smart @$$ remarks wernt needed.

clearly some of you dont deserve a black belt if you haven't mastered your pride. others need to get a life. dont go through the effort just to add a snide comment. however thanks to the few who can clear and informative information

little tip, no one will give **** about your reply if youre an *** about it. get your point across respectfully

16 Answers

Relevance
  • 8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Yes in a matter of fact there are several federations that give black belts to people that they pass their exams, even if they haven't trained with them. Now I am not quite certain if you just pass their black belt exam to get it, or if you also need to pass all their previous belts exams for this. I haven't checked that. But there are definitely a lot of federations that do it. Try to search in the net for this, I think you will find what you are looking for.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    Why not train in an art that has a complete system instead of having to go from art to another. Part of the problem with training in multiple systems is that at some point their philosophies clash and tend to cause more confusion than good. That's not to say you can't pick up and idea here and there which is a good thing. But making black belt is not the end all of that system. Black belt means that you've mastered the basics of the first level. It's after black belt when your really suppose to pick up the advanced principles. A true system of martial arts is based on actual principles. Not as a collection of techniques that you think are cool. Technique comes from principles it's not the other way around. Principles are the foundation from which an art is built upon and then expanded from that point onward. A tree cannot have branches without first growing it's roots. So to answer your question "no" you don't have to train in multiple systems. But there is nothing wrong with keeping an open mind and learning something new from time to time. I'm a believer in "mastering" one system, and learning all there is to know about it. Best of luck to you.

  • navolt
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    Earn Black Belt Online

  • 8 years ago

    You can learn all the moves from videos and books.

    You can buy a black belt and wear it.

    But... there are SO MANY little nuances and details that you will only learn from an experienced person who has the hours on the mat/in the ring/in the street and your own hours of experience from fighting many different people that really make it effective.

    A black belt is just a piece of cloth. The prisons are full of people who have killed with their bare hands and have no training what so ever.

    On another note, the black belt is not always the best guy in the dojo. Many times it's the brown belt who's getting ready to take all the black belts on.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 8 years ago

    Having a black belt and being a black belt are two different things. Black belts are determined by you being deserving of it in others eyes not your own.

    In Kyokushin Karate, Dan grades are expected to know all Katas pertaining to the rank, 100 push ups without stopping, hand stand for 90 seconds (honestly I don't know why this is a requirement but it is), and 10 rounds of non stop sparring. This is only the physical examination, some dojos require written tests as well.

    - Hope this helps

    Source(s): 9 years Kyokushin Karate (1st Dan), 5 years Judo (1st Kyu)
  • Emzii
    Lv 6
    8 years ago

    Of course you can just buy a belt and wear it, but it won't mean anything to any martial artist who actually trains at a dojo. Just get yourself to a dojo and see what the sensei thinks of you, they will give you a good idea of your standard.

    My black belt grading was:

    Kihon:

    Kizamazuki, oizuki, gyakuzuki x6

    Maegeri, oizuki, gyakuzuki x6

    Yoko geri, uraken, gyakuzuki x6

    Mawashi geri, uraken, gyakzuki x6

    Ushiro geri, urakan gyakuzuki x6

    Oizuki gyakuzuki, step back gedan barai, gyakuzuki, step forward yoko geri uraken gyakuzuki. x6

    Kata

    Bassai Dai followed by any of the Heian katas, the sensei could choose from any

    Kumite

    Jyu ippon kumite

    Jyu kumite

    That is the black belt grading, but obviously you'd have also had to pass every other grading with every other kata, kihon and kumite before you can even get there.

  • ?
    Lv 6
    8 years ago

    sure, youre good at throwing. but you have practiced throwing. you may even throw a good punch if you have been practicing on a bag. But good at fighting? you clearly cant fight/spar yourself. do you know what movements you are doing wrong? can your book tailor to your unique flaws?

    Worth a black belt? Black belt should mean "respect me, I could kill you", instead of todays " please dont touch me, im fragile". so many people, including you, just want that pretty belt around the waist. It de-values what a black belt used to stand for. I dont think you are half up to par with a black belt if you havent ever been in a fight. The only talent you say you have is knife throwing. commendable, but not worth a black belt.

  • Jim R
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    In my Shotokan style you will need about 5-10 years hard training 3 sessions a week and extras under a qualified set of instructors.

    Your previous "training" is as likely to hold you back as it is to help you.

    I have taught some of these home-made warriors, and they all have huge issues to correct.

  • 8 years ago

    Yeah sure. But if you want, just become a soldier without going through basic training or a doctor without going to med school. Screw it, aim high be an astronaut or a wizard.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    For the best answers, search on this site https://shorturl.im/awfVg

    You don't deserve to start your own style if you can't even spell sensei correctly

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.