Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

where were you born.?

10. Direct = "Where were you born?" he asked me.

Indirect = He wanted to know where I was born.

As you know we change the tense while converting a direct speech into an indirect speech.

I think "I was born" should have been "I had been born"

Because the first sentence or the direct sentence has used

simple past. So for indirect speech we should go one step further back which is

past perfect (had been).

Aren't I right?

This is the source:

http://www.myenglishpages.com/site_php_files/gramm...

4 Answers

Relevance
  • 8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Tenses have no bearing on whether speech is direct or indirect. Quotes are what make it direct. Consider these:

    Direct Speech

    "Where are you living?" he asked. -- Present

    "What will you be doing in Chicago?" he asked. -- Future

    "Where were you educated?" she inquired. -- Past

    Indirect Speech

    "He wanted to know where I attended high school." -- Past

    "They asked where I would be living if accepted into the school." -- Future

    "She asked which doctor I am seeing." -- Present

    Btw, even the asking of the question can be in another tense:

    Direct

    He asks, "Where were you born?"

    Indirect

    "He asks where I was born."

    Indirect (but in future tense)

    "He will ask where I was born."

    "I was born" is Simple Past, and you generally only every use the Simple Past when stating the place of your birth or to whom you were born. This is because you are born once and only once, and the event occurred during a clearly defined span of time. The only other time one would deviate from the Simple Past is if one said "I have been being born." OR "I am being born." These are the Continuous Present Perfect and Continuous Present, respectively. You would use the Continuous in creative writing.

    You cannot work all language rules out with logic and pattern, because that is not the way language works, certainly not English, which has many MANY parent languages -- languages that influenced it and/or added to its vocabulary.

  • Andrea
    Lv 5
    8 years ago

    The past perfect expresses the idea that something occurred before another action in the past. It can also show that something happened before a specific time in the past. Because you're not comparing 2 or more events, the simple past, especially with the verb "to be born," is the tense you want.

    Source(s): I'm a university English teacher. :-)
  • ?
    Lv 6
    8 years ago

    In the US, "where I was born" is right. It would never be "where I had been born".

    I think the same is true in the UK because in general the rules of grammar are the same, but sometimes there are small differences so I'm not absolutely sure.

  • 8 years ago

    No, the sentences are right.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.