Do I get a 2005 Ford Escape Hybrid or a 2003 Nissan Xterra?

Truth is, that's a ton of miles for either of these vehicles.

It's impossible to answer without knowing the maintenance history of either vehicle, but they are both going to be a huge gamble, on paper.

An Escape, gas or hybrid, is living on borrowed time with that many miles. A new hybrid battery will run you a couple grand if it needs to be replaced soon - probably will cost more than the car is worth.

The 2000-2004 Xterra is famous for radiator, engine and transmission issues right around the 120K mile mark. You may get lucky, but maybe not. A rebuilt transmission will cost you a couple grand so make sure you get it inspected by a professional to see if it was properly maintained.

Plus, the Xterra gets crap gas mileage and is awfully uncomfortable on long trips.

I think the Xterra is a lower risk if they are equally priced and it checks out, mechanically.

Of the two I think the Nissan would be the better choice but you need to have it inspected by a good mechanic before you purchase. Older Hybrids such as the Escape have the potential for major problems. Good Luck

I watch the show House Hunters where a couple has to choose between 3 houses. Different subject but same issue. Many times my answer to the couple on House Hunters is the same answer I give to you "keep looking". Look for that needle in the haystack. Wait for that SUV that belonged to a little old lady with 60K miles. It's out there be patient.

nissan