Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Hindus: question?
As I get more involved in Hinduism, I'm realizing just how many Indian-born Hindus frown upon Westerners associating themselves with Hinduism.
I've been told that a white Hindu is an 'oxymoron' and that I will not be allowed into a mandir (despite the fact I know many Western-born white Hindus who visit temples regularly, and they're not affiliated with ISKCON).
So, I've decided, that if people are angry if I identify as 'Hindu' than I will not go by that term. After all, "Hindu" is not even in Indian word, it comes from the Persian 'Hindhu' reffering to the people across the Sindhu (Indus) river. But what is your opinion on me still reading the Gita? Performing pujas? Fasting on festival days? Chanting Om Namah Shivaya and the Gayatri mantra? Can I still do that or am I too white to find Sanatana Dharma?
5 Answers
- philosophyangelLv 77 years ago
Hinduism is a term for a vast culture and also a range of religious expression. Traditional Hindu culture applies itself to the caste system and identifies non-ethnic Hindus as outsiders (expatriated Hindus, technically speaking, forfeit their caste status but this technicality is not observed). There also are restrictions at many temples in India that bar entry to nonethnic Hindus. That said, there are some Hindu groups and sects that allow non Hindus to formally convert to the sect or simply identify as an adherent of that particular form of Hindu religion. For example, I have identified as a reformed Vedantist --affiliated with the Vedanta Society and Ramakrishna Math--for the past 35 years. I live in America, though. However, because this sect of Vedanta was missionized throughtout the world in the early 20th century, clergy and followers are of all nationalities, and if I went to India, I would be recognized as a Vedantist and have access to sites governed by the Vedanta Society. This hospitality would not necessarily be extended to other religious institutions in India, though. Besides, "being Hindu" is complex-- as is "being Buddhist." Westerners generally adopt and adapt some beliefs and customs and then misguidedly label themselves "Hindu" or "Buddhist" without really knowing what that means or how to apply it.
- 7 years ago
Hinduism is a religion. Anyone should be able to follow any religion they choose. Coming from a fellow Hindu, I think these rules are discriminative. Keep performing rituals and chanting, pujas, etc. it's all your choice. I don't know why Indian Hindus would be like that.. I've seen white Hindus before. But Indians (NOT ALL) can be a bit.. Conservative. And strict with things like this. But you know what? Break tradition. You want to be known as a Hindu, be a Hindu. And if you are proud of that, show it to the world. Best of luck!
- ssrvjLv 77 years ago
One Response:-"What is your Caste ?
In India you have to have a caste , if you are a Hindu.
The right to become Priest is only reserved to Brahmin Caste."
This is a LIE.--FULL LIE.
In Indian Sub-Continent Hindus-Muslims-Christians-Sikhs even JEWS have CASTE.
If a Person genuinely wants to Practice Hindu Religion,he/she would NOT be worried about others--Asking for "RECOGNITION" is NOT a Hindu Conceptual Tenet.
Persons with ALL Skin Colours practice Hindu Religion.
- DeepakLv 47 years ago
Education level in India is 'developing' just like the economy. So may be the mob may stare at you for being an odd sheep in the flock but never mind that...coz they are not used to it.
You are always welcome.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- 7 years ago
What is your Caste ?
In India you have to have a caste , if you are a Hindu.
The right to become Priest is only reserved to Brahmin Caste.