Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Spanish grammar: college 202 accents?
My Spanish professor (from Colombia) corrected the word "vi," as in, "I saw," to "ví." He has also added an accent to the word "si," meaning "if." Is this a Colombian thing? I don't want to change my paper since I am pretty sure that I need to write "vi" not "ví." All opinions/thoughts are welcome!
2 Answers
- VerdecilloLv 57 years agoFavorite Answer
Well, your professor is indeed mistaken. The main purpose of written accent marks in Spanish is to indicate irregular syllabic stress. Since the word "vi" is monosyllabic (i.e. it consists of only one syllable), there is no reason for it have a written accent. Besides the irregular stress indication, written accents are also used to avoid homonyms (i.e. words otherwise spelled and pronounced the same but with different meanings). This latter purpose is why there is the word "si" meaning "if" contrasted with the word "sí" meaning "yes" (in addition to others like "que" vs. "qué"; "tu" vs. "tú"; "el" vs. "él"; "mas" vs. "más"; etc.). Anyway, even though your professor is wrong, these particular orthographic rules are quite unknown to most Spanish speakers. I am not saying that he should not know them, indeed he should (after all, he is a professor of Spanish), but still, I agree with the advice that * 阿妹* May * gave- just bring it to his attention in a courteous way.
Source(s): I am a linguist, language teacher, and translator- I speak and teach Spanish (among other languages). - * 阿妹* May *Lv 77 years ago
Some Spanish speakers write the way they speak, so that may be the case here. One of my friends always writes "Boy a la playa" instead of "voy".
You can always talk to him during office hours about it; just say that you're confused and that what's in the text book is different from what he's teaching/writing. Ask him to help you out that way (instead of just making it sound like he's wrong).