Guy #1 or guy #2?

I've been stuck between these two guys, I'm in high school so I know I shouldn't worry but i just wanna get opinions.

Guy #1: my ex that goes to a different school, I always think people break up for a reason, we broke up about 2 months ago bc he started acting ghetto, starting going to house twerk parties although he said he was just going to see his friends. He's not the type of guy to cheat but still bothered me. But we have this connection and were so comfortable w each other, but I wanna tell me parents (I can date) but I don't like the stuff he was doing and he knows and he changed I guess but I'm still unsure.

Guy #2: this guy who has a girlfriend. He's dating a girl I know on my team but I'm not that close to her because she's so quite and it's hard to even talk to her because she's so shy. And the guy is so funny and sweet. They're not in a serious relationship at all it's only been 1 month and he said she different in text verses in person. I'm not, plus her parents don't kmow. I would tell my parents about him if we dated because he lives right by me and I have a class w him and we text everyday. So it would be easy to hang out and be in a serious relationship with him. He told me the other day he liked me before he dated the girl he's daying now and he still does. He always asks me to go outside but it doesn't seem like he's gonna break up w his girlfriend. And he's not the player type at all even tho that made him sound like it