Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
During WW2, did the Jewish population IN ITALY suffer the same fate as in other countries allied with or conquered by Germany?
I can't go to the library because I am disabled, so I ask here, because Google doesn't offer much on the subject of Italy's Jewish Population from 1936-1945.
What was the fate of the Jews in Italy? Also; I am curious Why I have never heard anything about Them, in all the books and documentaries I have studied on World War Two and also on the Holocaust. The fate of Italy's Jewish population has been rarely, if ever, mentioned in things I've seen. I wonder why? I hope maybe they were spared?
5 Answers
- spiffer1Lv 76 years ago
In some ways Mussolini was a 'Hitler wannabe' but never measured up. Italy was not united under fascism to the same extent as Germany was united under Nazism.
Mussolini was not antisemitic as was Hitler. This caused a rift between the two. When Germany moved into Italy after Italy switched sides, the Nazis tried to (or started to) introduce their antisemitic policies.
Currently members of the families of survivors are publishing works on the holocaust which contain primary source material. Best to consult these works and look for them as they come out in print.
Dictators were deemed the personification of the nation - in that what they dictated became the will, aim, goal, purpose and mission of the nation with all members of that nation called upon to dutifully and without question follow this will locked in step.
- 6 years ago
Attitudes toward the Jews illustrates one key difference between Fascism and Nazism.
This isn't a chicken-and-egg distinction...
Does the Nation make the State, or does the State Make the Nation?
For fascists like Mussolini, the STATE makes the NATION. The idea of being a member of society is a creation of the state, and the citizenry created and organized BY the state, exists to serve the state, To that end, Mussolini didn't care about being anti-Semitic. In fact, one of the founders of the Italian Fascist Party WAS a Jew. Since the idea of "Italian-ness" was a construct of the state, a person's religion or ethnicity was effectively meaningless.
Under Mussolini, certain anti-Jewish laws were passed (to placate Hitler), but there were no pogroms against the Jews. Widespread expulsion of the Jews and deportation to death camps didn't occur until 1943 when the Italian government fell and the Nazis occupied Italy. But this was done under the auspices of the Germans, NOT the Italians.
For Nazism, though, the NATION makes the STATE. Nazism preached the doctrine of the pure Aryan Race, and the state is created BY the Nation and exists to serve it. Thus, for Nazis, racial matters mattered a great deal. Hence their preoccupation with the Jews.
Hope that answers your question
- ammianusLv 76 years ago
Yes,once Mussolini had been deposed and German forces occupied Italy.
Read 'If This is a Man' by Primo Levi - he was an Italian Jew sent to Auschwitz.
So,ideas that Italian Jews were not treated the same as Jews in other countries are wholly false - once the Germans took control of Italy in 1943.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous6 years ago
not to the same extent.