Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Question who death was more emotional dumbledore or Gandalf?
I’ll have to go with Gandalf’s being the saddest death scene not only just that but the music was a masterpiece!!
3 Answers
- Anonymous5 months ago
I recently watched all three of the Peter Jackson directed LOTR movies and guess what? I don't care.
- ?Lv 75 months ago
In the books
Dumbledore's
because you were never really sure that Gandalf was dead
until he showed up again and told you that he had died (well, SORT of died).
With Dumbly
I was convinced that he had faked his death (which happened very near to the end of "The Half-Blood Prince" [THBP])
but of course it turned out I was wrong.
It just seemed like Dumbly had (probably, once again) fooled everyone and was going to reappear in the next book.
BUT in THBP there was a funeral and everything.
It DID SEEM as if he had really died
and everyone reacted as if he had really died.
Of course
everyone in TLOTR also acted as if Gandalf had died
but they were on a mission
and didn't have a body
and so didn't have a funeral
and didn't really have time to mope about or eulogize like they did in THBP
(in TLOTR the mourning was glossed over VERY quickly)
and it didn't happen at the end of the book, but in the first third of the book.
Note that shortly after Gandalf's "death", Boromir died, and for real. So: there was another death, a more certain death, only a little later in the story, and THAT death had a funeral, eulogy, etc.