Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
OK - What happens to time if part of the the universe does not exist in a vacuum?
Einstein arrived at some of his ideas by picturing himself riding on a beam of light. What if that beam were slower due to passing through a medium? Would that affect simultaneity across the boundary of the medium? Wouldn't distant stars be seen in the more distant past? We know that time runs slower on the outside of a rotating disk than it does on the inside. Does time run at a slightly different rate underwater? This has no effect on relativity - in fact, I am trying to live within the confines of relativity.
Excuse me -
I was basing Einstein's statement regarding riding on a beam of light on The Ascent of Man, which was written by Jacob Bronowski (who knew Einstein personally I believe) and Cosmos by Carl Sagan, who used to work in pretty much the same job Dr Zikzak held. I guess you gentlemen know more than they do.
I have taken a class in relativity, and during that class I found that the professor was much easier to talk to and ask similar questions of than you gentlemen, who seem so over-impressed by your own admittedly superior knowledge that you respond by intimidation.
I understand that c is a fixed speed. I have understood that for decades. What I do not understand so well is how time works and how it is perceived. Thanks anyway.
2 Answers
- ZikZakLv 61 decade agoFavorite Answer
>Einstein arrived at some of his ideas by picturing himself riding on a beam of light.
No he did not. Einstein knew very well, very early on that it is not possible to ride on a beam of light.
>What if that beam were slower due to passing through a medium?
This makes no difference. By axiom, it is the invariant speed c=3*10^5 km/s that is the fundamental quantity. It just so happens that light in vacuum travels at this speed. It is not the properties of light that are important; it is the properties of speed.
It makes no difference whatsoever that sometimes light is slowed down in media. Time does not pass at a different rate in water, because in water, the invariant velocity is still c, even though the speed of a particular light ray is slower than c.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Typically questions which have "Einstein said "or "Einstein arrived" are based on a total misunderstanding of physics. Please do not start a question like that. Just state what you want to know instead of putting your own faulty idea into Einstein's mouth.
Your "question" is so convoluted and far from reality that I wouldn't even know where to start correcting you.
Please take a real class on relativity, then come back with questions. As is, you are not even wrong.
