Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Christians - do you believe in fate, destiny and soul mates?
If so, please explain how free will exists if there's already a plan laid out for you.
Jin - if destiny is forseen by god as you put it then how do you really have a choice? How can free will exist if god has already saw what you are going to do?
It's like The Matrix when the oracle told Neo not to worry about the vase and then proceeded to say that what would really tickle his noodle later was would he have still broken it if she hadn't said anything. She saw it happen in advance, she knew it was going to happen and then it happened. How can free will exist if the outcome has already been fortold?
How much choice do you have when selecting a "soul mate"? If a soul mate truly exists, then you have no choice in the matter.
7 Answers
- 1 decade agoFavorite Answer
rebel if a guy's destiny is a fat chick, purchase a one way ticket on the Amtrak rails.
- CharlesLv 61 decade ago
No to all three. Nor does "free will" involve them.
If you had bothered to do a search you would have found a number of entries that are a part of most good intro philosophy courses on the apparent dilemma of free will vs. determinism.
Knowledge of the future is possible for humans, and such knowledge doesn't seem to commit us to the view that our actions are completely determined. Many parents have the experience of knowing what their children will do even before the children know."I knew you'd do that (say that, touch that, etc.)" is not an uncommon expression. The fact that a parent has this knowledge doesn't seem to compell the child to behave that way.
So, someone having full knowledge of the future need not remove the notion of free will.
HTH
Charles
- 1 decade ago
We all have choices, and we are fully responsible for them.
God is all-knowing and omnipresent. He has His plan, and He's fully in control over all things. His will works out to His ends just as He says it will be. God has made and knows all of us, so He knows what makes us tick and He can control our circumstances so that there's only 1 real option if we love Him and 1 other option if we hate Him.
In everything choice we have, it is always geared towards a choice between loving and hating God. Ultimately, God knows where we will fail and where we'll succeed. He uses our good and bad decisions to amplify His glory and to let it be known. Every choice you're given in life was set before you because God let it happen. God's purposes, are His own but His intentions ultimately are to bring you closer to Him.
Man-kind has an arrogant image of itself (as a whole) and they believe they can fully understand and know all things about God (usually this is assumed upon the platform of God not existing or God being less than Almighty). We can never fully understand how an infinite God has absolute control and yet we still have a free will with a free choice.
I personally know that God is too awesome to sum up in a statement or even in a large series of books. It's not that we don't have a free will, but we're so limited in understanding compared to God that we are a variable God is able to "work around" so to speak. Not that God is constantly making adjustments, but that God knows the full consequence of every action both man's and His. He makes the perfect actions to ensure His plan unfolds as He intends, nothing can stop it. Understand, it's not God's will against ours. God designs our will to work for His purposes.
Really the question should be directed more towards the purpose of your life as opposed to the control you have over your own life.
- NebulousLv 61 decade ago
No, no and no.
God's knowledge of the future (omniscience) and control of the present and future (predestination) are not the same thing. We can chose to follow God's plans or to oppose them (or make faulty choices based on a misunderstanding of God's plans, like the revolting Phelps cult).
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- ArmandLv 41 decade ago
I believe in soulmates. And destiny is forseen by God but chosen by me.
By the way, fate and destiny are the same thing.
- Anthony CLv 61 decade ago
so what if God knew, you still came to the decision with no prior knowledge of the outcome.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Fate? No
Destiny? No
Soul Mates? No
There is no plan laid out for me, I make my own way and my own decisions. knowing what someone will do is not the same as causing them to do it.