Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Why do so many veterans groups oppose McCain?

"[McCain] received a grade of D from the Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America and a 20 percent vote rating from the Disabled Veterans of America; Vietnam Veterans of America noted McCain had “voted against us” in 15 “key votes.”

As for the American Legion and the Veterans of Foreign Wars — with whom McCain claims to have a “perfect voting record” — both groups vigorously supported Sen. Jim Webb’s (D-VA) GI Bill that McCain tirelessly opposed."

http://thinkprogress.org/2008/07/08/mccain-veteran...

NOTE: obama received a B+ from IAVA and 80% from Disabled Veterans of America. who's really in support of the troops and vets here?

Update:

re: tedkennedysbrainrot: directly from the websites cited:

"The 1.3 million-member Disabled American Veterans (DAV) is a non-profit organization founded in 1920 and chartered by the U.S. Congress in 1932"

"Founded in June 2004, Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America is the nation's first and largest group dedicated to the Troops and Veterans of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan"

as far as i recall, both of those dates were before kerry's loss.

Update 2:

re: thinkprogress is biased.

i agree. but if you go to the websites of iava and disabled vets, they are not biased. i just linked to the thinkprogress entry because they summed it up nicely. can't argue with the links to the vets grps:

http://capwiz.com/dav/scorecard.xc

http://www.iava.org/full-ratings-list

Update 3:

re: you can find a group to support anything!

so if there are pro-mccain and anti-mccain veterans groups i suppose that we can safely say that some veterans support mccain and some support obama. i guess now we can stop making the silly claim that obama is somehow against the troops while mccain supports them, right?

Update 4:

re: call me bwana

well if legislation is not the measure of a politician's support how the heck do you measure it? you just know in your gut that mccain has "true" support for the troops while he votes to deny them benefits?

17 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I lost a great deal of respect for McCain when he voted against Webb's bill. And then, when he claimed that it is "unconstitutional" for congress to make rules concerning the management of our forces, I realized that he is not a constitutional conservative.

    Source(s): Article 1, Section 8, Chapter 14 clearly states that congress shall make rules concerning the management of our military. http://www.house.gov/house/Constitution/Constituti... If McCain believed that Webb's proposal was unsustainable, that's one thing. But, I expect the President to know what the US Constitution says. The people who want to turn a blind eye to the negatives of one candidate, because that candidate is from a particular political party, are doing us all great harm.
  • 5 years ago

    i'm a veteran and picture McCains invoice is extra lifestyles like- college is expensive yet none people became promised an entire unfastened experience in common terms for doing 3-4 yrs. it truly is like the VA, we've been informed we'd get centers if we've been given injured on duty or if we retired not for 2,3,4 yrs of provider yet by some means that have been given prolonged and now the VA has a stressful time getting the interest achieved for those in want because of the fact they ought to divert supplies to those who shouldnt be recieving the convenience. What the dems dont enable you realize is that vets with 30% or extra incapacity can get a level paid for thoroughly besides as a month-to-month stipend- i understand first hand I hate the election twelve months political video games and the certainty that the style of good sort of fall for it.

  • 1 decade ago

    These groups of which I am a menmber of one of them feel that after the debates were over that McCain would and has both verbally and on record constantly said that these organizations were being paid too much already and that he would not support any kind of increase for them . Instead he would try to buy them out ( one time Payment ) or do away with some of what they already have . Obama on the other hand as charasmatic as he is

    saw the handwriting on the wall about these groups and knowing that these groups could carry a candidate or cause him lots of headaches, took the opposite stand of McCain . It sounds good , but what the h###

    does Obama know about war or foreign affairs? the answer to that question is absolutely nothing . Obama's promises of change in this country are full of hot air . He promises change , but never says what those changes are going to be or who they will affect .If Obama says he sympathizes with the veterans or if he says he empathizes with the vet , he is flat out lying. He has never spent one day in uniform much less a war .

    He is running one one thing alone and it may , quite possibly will , get him elected . He is running on the race issue only . that is the only issue he is familiar with . He has only been a congressman for one year and has no experience at all in foreign affairs , unless you count all the time he has spent in Iraq and running down this country . We all have freedom of choice inour vote and you should get out and vote on the candidate of your choice , but do not vote for a man by the color of his skin , and on the other side of that , do not vote against the man because of the color of his skin . Is McCain the best candidate , who knows but I do know that McCain has more years in a prisoner of war camp, not knowing if he would get to see this country or his family again . and that is five years more than Obama has in congress . One thing that really bothers me is If Obama is trying to BS the American people by saying he is pro veteran groups , then why did he turn his back on the flag , refuse to put his hand over his heart , and refuse to sing the national Anthem , if he is true to what he says in his campaign.

    Somewhere in all that he is not being truthful with us , but he sure wants us to believe he is .

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    You can't really judge support based on legislation. There are many reasons why legislation might be voted for or against, especially if there are riders or earmarks attached.

    I'll trust in McCain's true support of the vets over Obama's, any day.

    ---------

    Let me use smaller words so you can grasp this simple concept. If I write legislation for national health care but include a rider to put all Democrats in concentration camps, and you vote against it, does that mean you're against national health care?

    The Democrats have been attaching a lot of crap to bills, especially earmarks and other unrelated stuff.

    So don't go all naive and unsophisticated on me - you leftwingers are self-anointed "intellectuals".

    Try keeping up.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Well it seems to me that the returning Vet's will not put up with McCain lying about supporting the troops nor supporting the Vets.

    Vet's from all over the US is going to McCain's town hall meeting and asking him why he voted against all the vet's bill for the past seven years.

    The Vets are even pissed off that he refused to vote for the bill that says will we not use any type of torture.

  • 1 decade ago

    Well, most veteran groups do NOT oppose McCain. And McCain authored his own GI Bill, which is why he opposed Jim Webb's. Maybe you should do some additional research from less biased sources. **snicker**

    But it was a good attempt at spin. LOL

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    thinkprogress is a COMMUNIST organization! The miltary supports Mccain by at least 80% if not more. You are TOTALLY dishonest even suggesting that when history dictates otherwise!

    Webb's bill is a pork-laden flop! Mccain is trying to pass a much better one and you guys KNOW it! McCain has two sons in the Military also!

    Source(s): Obama has in the last week turned down meetings with two current miltary groups because he doesn't want to answer their questions!
  • 1 decade ago

    Considering the past history of the veterans groups you mentioned it is almost a certainty that would oppose anyone on the Republican ticket and support anyone on the Democrat ticket. They certainly not representative of most vets.

  • pebble
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    With the internet today you can always find some source that states whatever it is you want it to. The trick is finding a CREDIBLE source. Keep looking dear.

    LOL, No, still looking for that credible source. Just can't find anything better can you? ah well, time to move on.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    What can I say: he voted AGAINST the new G.I.bill, he voted against giving Veterans better benefits---and he still lives in the Vietnam era---this is not a war that can be won with old techniques from back then.....McCain is too old....and he doesn't care about his fellow veterans.....that's why veterans do not favor him....

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.