Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

shiariryu asked in PetsDogs · 1 decade ago

People aggression.... only not.?

I have a 15 month old English Shepherd mix. The ES is particularly noted for its strong guardian instincts. Normally this has limited itself to quiet "mom, something's weird"-type wuffs or barking at the door if someone shows up late at night. However, last week while on a very late night walk I stopped to chat with someone and then noticed that my dog was very intently staring at something behind me. I turned to look at noticed an older woman standing in the gate to her garden, in the shadows. After a few moments she started to walk forward and my dog went nuts, lunging and bark-growling and generally sounding like he wanted to rip her to shreds.

This reaction was completely abnormal for him. Usually everyone is "bestest friend ever love joy cookies!" to my dog, even at night. And even after this incident, he was excited-happy bouncing whenever we'd walk by someone on the way home. The only difference I can see is that the woman was "hiding".

So, I would love some advice on *channeling* his protectiveness nature, not shutting it down entirely. Any comments to that effect will be ignored. I feel that attempting to remove from him entirely a behaviour that was *bred into* the breed on purpose will only lead to a breakdown sometime in the future that could have disastrous results.

Also, I would love some references for appropriate trainers in the San Francisco Bay Area of california, if anyone who sees this lives around there. My pup has been... interesting to try to train due to his sometimes aggravating tendency to think and reason his way around a command. Such as a "down stay" clearly.... means that he needs to stay laying down! Thus inching forward slowly is completely okay, so long as he's still laying down. He's only finally starting to learn that stay means "in this location".

Update:

Forgot to add:

Major reason for this question... He would not listen when he was acting protective of me. That is what has me worried. What if the lady had been within leash-reach? What if I'd been paying less attention and he managed to yank the leash away from me?

Normally when he's doing either his warnings or at-the-door barks, he'll listen if I say "It's okay!" and turn back into his normal happy self. There was no chance in hell during this encounter and I had to literally drag him away.

While I like the fact that if someone jumps out of a bush to get me my dog will defend me.... 70 year old women are not much of a threat! I need him to trust me to assess the situation and if I say there's no reason to be defensive, I need him to turn it off.

Update 2:

To Karen:

Did you even read my whole question? I said that I do NOT want to get rid of his protectiveness... but rather channel it! I can't have him continuing to act like there is a threat once I have determined there is none. I also want to try to get him to stand and alert, rather than immediately rush over. Right now he's an exuberant "teenager", and thus prone to rash decisions. What if it had been a child who was coming towards me, with me unable to make my dog cease wanting to attack?

I do NOT want to have to euthanise my dog someday because he bit someone while thinking he had to defend me... but instead bit someone harmless!

8 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I think this might be an isolated incident.

    If he's never done it before, maybe something about that woman creeped him out. Remember, dogs can smell things like illness and cancer, in addition to perfumes and detergents. Maybe she just really stinks. He got annoyed by the smell.

    Don't know any trainers in the Bay Area. If you wanted to drive into Sacramento, look up All Breeds Dog Training. They're excellent.

    As for "channeling" him, well, like I said, it doesn't seem like an ongoing problem.

    When he starts up, say "That'll do", and make him sit. Put your body between whoever he's barking at and give the command. It teaches him you want to know about potential danger, but not to go insane, and to let you handle the issue.

    I just love a cleaver dog!

    LOL!!!

    I've seen bumper stickers that say "My Shepard is smarter than your Honor Student"! and it's so true I just have to laugh.

    I hope I helped.

    Cheers.

  • 1 decade ago

    I would not call your dog aggressive after just one episode, and especially in this situation, if people stand still it often freaks dogs out, you should see mine if they sit on a seat and don't move, she thinks it's a monster. You have learnt something about your dog that is important, that he can get spooked and react.

    He sounds like a real character, the dogs with most character are the ones hardest to train as they have the most intelligence.

    Edit

    You need to teach him a key word that means ATTENTION, list to Mum. Pick a word that you do not use very often, I use Oye. Train at home by dropping something like a teaspoon or teabag, when he goes to sniff it, yell the word and charge towards him. He should react in a rather horrified fashion and run away. Do NOT reassure him or treat him, this is what you want, his complete attention. Just ignore him and go back to what you were doing. If he does not react, get a large flattened box and use it to push him away, rather violently. This is a great word that can be used when you are in need of quick action and want him to stop focusing on something and on you. His reaction should be to stop what he is doing and to run away, this will stop him biting another person if you fear it.

  • 5 years ago

    It looks you've inherited a few behaviour problems. The the very first thing you have got to do is reap your puppies believe. FOOD will do that. Good behaviour is rewarded with a small piece of tasty however healthful doggie deal with, (dried liver or bird portions). Start sensible - fundamental instructions - Sit, Stay, Down, Come. Until you and your puppy have this taken care of out who's the '% chief' (boss) you'll preserve to have behaviour problems. You ought to consistently keep calm and use sluggish nonthreatening pursuits while coaching, a minimum of half-hour an afternoon. No unexpected pursuits and use really however corporation instructions - no obedience no deal with. Whilst you're having biting issues I might no longer take the domestic dog to obedience till she has settled. You look to be at the correct monitor. If she continues to be biting by way of coaching then as prompt use a muzzle. No treats - placed her instantly on a series in her kennel or comfortable her in her room and forget about. Try once more in an hour and repeat till she learns. That's the thrill facet of being a partner for a puppy, studying in combination combined with play with obedience and tons of affection. Good good fortune.

  • 1 decade ago

    Your dog noticed something appeared odd to him in the middle of the night on a walk and reacted accordingly saying 'I dont think I am comfortable with what is over there'. I don't expect my dog to greet most people like an old friend on a walk in the middle of the night either! I would hardly call this an aggressive incident. I doubt he even knew it was a human.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • karen.
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    no way lady,he is a dog!you absoultly can not try to change this aspect of him,he sees his purpose in life is to protect you.i have 2 ridgebacks they gaurd.its not something i have ever told them to do,they just do.i would say the dog was gaurding you but with very good reason.someone was hiding,and by you own admision you didnt see them first fido did,and while you might be in sound mind about making decions ect,you didnt know someone was there untill fido told you.your lucky it was on old lady wernt you?could have been a rapist couldnt it?youd sure as hell want him to gaurd then wouldnt you.you need to learn about dogs and stop giving fido a hard time for doing his thing.

    Source(s): 2 rhodesion ridgebacks.excellent gaurd bogs!
  • Elly
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    Your dog may have been reacting to the old woman's bad energy. She was probably hiding because she is afraid of dogs, and your dog sensed her fear and reacted to it. I generally try to avoid people who are afraid of dogs because they overreact, and may cause accidents to happen.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Would be because he thought that the old bird was a threat, or that he didnt know where she was and couldnt see what she was like,

    how you said that she was in the shadows.

  • Kate C
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    I dont think your dog was wrong in reacting that way.

    Your dog realized the person was there and that you did not and warned you.

    Source(s): Owner of three dogs that hopefully would do the same. http://www.flyingdogpress.com/sayhi.html www.bigdogsporch.com
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.