Manny Ramirez or Alex Rodriguez?

Does Manny have a second job at The Daily Planet?

Is that blue head scarf actually a cape?

Was Manny born on this planet?

What Manny has done for the Dodgers has been absolutely phenomenal. The younger Dodgers are in complete awe of a, so far, happy to be a Dodger, Manny.

GO MANNY!!

Hi

Well Arod is one the Best with manny and they will always be on the top in my Book and with Stats many wins because of what he does in the Postseason and people look for that, and personality goes also a big part in the like Factor but I would choose Arod because for some reason even tough he gets me and i know what he is Capable of

i am a yankees fan, but manny is much more clutch than A-Rod. Just look at their post season records. I would take Manny over A-Rod any day. A-rod only makes numbers when it is unnecessary. He hits home runs when the yanks are up by like ten. no comparison, Manny wins.

You pretty much answered your question. Manny Ramirez produces more crucial hits in clutch situations than A-Rod, and his post-season RBI production is monstrous compared to Rodriguez. To top it off, his two World Series rings certainly proved his status in the playoff. The inability to come up with clutch hits with running in scoring positions cast a big shadow on A-Rod's otherwise brilliant career.

So if I had to choose between them, right now, I'd still choose Manny over A-Rod.

So if people compare A Rod to other players like Manny or Pujols & they say they are better than A Rod cause they have a World Series ring does that mean those same players are better than let's say Ted Williams, Ernie Banks or Harmon Killebrew who are all in HOF but haven't won a WS or any other HOFer who hasn't won a WS? Just my thoughts?

I would take Manny in the clutch but A-Rod as a guy on my team everyday. I couldn't deal with the silliness of manny everyday.

I would say both are favored for creating a media frenzy. but as a performer i'd say Manny Ramirez because of the venue he plays at. In NY they expect so much from you, and you have tougher fans. In LA, things are more relaxed, you're still expected to perform but it doesn't seem to be as grueling on someone. Its all about perspectives.

This is a very interesting question. One of the keys is that Rodriquez is 4 years younger than Manny, so I think by the time all is said and done A-Rod will top him. Manny's attitude is a big negative too, but he is still a remarkable, Hall of Fame hitter.

And please people, let's grow up with the "Gayrod" comments.

Manny Ramirez. He used to play with the Indians & I was fortunate to see him play several times. He makes things happen on the field wether its at bat or in the outfield. When he played for Cleveland they we contenders 3 years in a row. He is a very consistent ball player most of the time. Like any other athlete, he has his moments. I still watch him play. =o`)

Is this a trick Question? A-Rod the Snot could not tie Manny's shoes. Manny is a big time clutch hitter where A-rod is all about his stats, A-rod is a CANCER to what ever team he plays on!