Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Why do people think Israel should risk its people's lives to save Palestinians?
'Israel’s efforts to destroy missiles before they can be fired at Israeli civilians, even if that places Palestinian civilians at risk, seems to conform perfectly to the Laws of War.
There is no requirement that Israel place the lives of its own citizens in danger to protect the lives of Palestinian civilians.'
Is this right?
15 Answers
- 1 decade agoFavorite Answer
Ocean, it's like bombing a building because murderous convicts are taking people hostage while remotely destroying other buildings. This is the best solution, albeit a hard, terrible one. Would you rather that Israel let the convicts keep bombing their buildings and their civilians? A life is a life. Israel has the right to defend itself just like any other country.
My stepmom is in Be'er Sheva, which is in range of Hamas missiles which come in daily by the dozens. I hope she will be alright. Likewise, I hope as many civilians on both sides as possible survive.
- 1 decade ago
Excellent question, you have a really good point. This is war and Israel has a right AND A DUTY to defend their tax paying citizens. They should not place the lives of their citizens in any kind of danger to protect the lives of Palestinians.
Go ahead, ask some more questions, because I am tired of all the ignorant repetitive pointless ones the majority are posting.
- Trader GLv 61 decade ago
War is not a game. You do not keep score going tit for tat. War is a last resort and the intention of war is to destroy the enemy. The tools of war are weapons. If someone uses a knife then you use a gun. If they use a gun then you use a greater weapon (an equalizer) the weapons of today have what are called killing fields. When they are employed then everything within that field dies. That is the grim reality; think about it before you go about attacking your neighbor. If a Chihuahua attacks a German Shepard don't be surprised that the Shepard kills the Chihuahua. The Chihuahua should have never attacked the Shepard in the first place. Hamas. has an idiotic charter and their leaders are idiotic murderers. The deaths of their women and children are a direct result of their leaders' actions. Unfortunately there are too many people who who too dimwitted to see beyond the ruble.
- mccloskyLv 45 years ago
this is suited. inspite of the actuality that, Israel does take substantial risks which it has no criminal accountability to, with the intention to guard Palestinians. It suffered by way of 1000's of rocket assaults earlier taking militia action. It warns Palestinian neighborhoods earlier attacking, to enable them to evacuate, even nonetheless this expenses Israel the total thing approximately marvel. in many procedures Israel does address better threat with the intention to cut back the prospect to Palestinian civilians. And it quite is Hamas that reasons lots of civilians to be crowded around their militia and weapons websites, inflicting them to be caught contained in the crossfire. Israel has been bombarded each and every day for 8 years, and Hamas has signaled its objective to expand the assaults on Israel extremely than scuffling with them. If Israel isn't suicidal, it might desire to look after itself by employing doing away with the Hamas weapons and management. Israel had no longer occupied Gaza provided that 2005. Hamas did no longer choose a Palestinian state as much because it had to break Israel.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- darkAILv 51 decade ago
They think they should because they lack knowledge and information. For example, take the 2 bozos above me.
Ocean said that Gaza is not independent. Well, that's partly true, partly false. Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, making it completely independent as not a single soldier was there. Israel still provides them with free water, free electricity, free food and sometimes even free health care, but that's only because the Palestinians invest the 3+ billion dollar aid they receive into weapons instead of rebuilding their independent Gaza.
As for Sica, yet another clueless people who has no clue what he's talking about, as over 9000 Israelies were injured, crippled or killed by Palestinian terrorism since 2000. See for yourself:
http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Terrorism-+Obstacle+to+P...
So if you take this lack of knowledge, mix it with a bit of propaganda and anti-semism, you get a great recipe for saying Israel is bad for defending its own civilians.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Yes, because Israeli's are the chosen people in a stolen country a hospital or school is a good target. Because Israel herded Palestinians into a concentration camp (Gaza) that makes civilians a legitimate target. Israel does not protect anything except stolen land.
- 1 decade ago
Yes the rules of war. I saw that Israel while shelling has trucks with relieft supplies in the long line of other countries supplies.
The areas set aside for the Palestinians to have a place to call home, wasnt meant to be used as a weapon storage to shell Israel.
- mov ah, 4chLv 61 decade ago
Yes, it is. Israel does more then enough to divert the harm from civilians. Most of other armies of the world won't do that.
- sasyoneLv 51 decade ago
I agree with you,every government has the responsibility to protect their citizens,all except the government of Hamas,It doesn't show that they care about the people or children dying on their streets for if they cared they surely wouldn't keep launching those rockets into Israel.It's very sad for the families caught in the middle of this war.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
I tend to agree with you. Israel experiences many rocket attacks per year and has tried to use diplomacy and lower levels of force to pressure Palestinians to stop attacking them but this has not worked. Israel is simply taking the next logical step and using overwhelming force to end the threat of Palestinian rocket attacks. However it is unfortunate that in this type of warfare civilians tend to get hurt or even killed but we must remember that if they don't want Israel to attack them than they need to pressure their government to stop terrorists from launching rockets against Israel.