Are the All-american girl next door type attracted to guys with a bit of a bad boy look?

Can a good, educated guy with a bit of a bad boy look get an educated all american girl next door type? I was just wondering because in one of my grad school classes, there is this girl who looks like a pre-tom cruise era katie holmes. You can tell she is straighted laced and from the suburbs and all of that. A lot of my friends were like yeah she would probably go to a movie with you or a drink, but that is it even though you are educated, have a good job, are a good guy, etc. because you have a bit of a bad boy look. I have like 14 tattoos and used to have piercings but took them out to look more mature/clean cut. What do you think? They were saying in general, they would maybe date me casually and be a fling but that is it. They wouldn't be too likely to get serious or long-term because I don't have that yuppie/preppy look of the guy they always saw themselves marrying and were raised up around as little girls as far as other kids' parents and older siblings' spouses. Is this true? What do you think. I know that there is always an exception, but what about the likelihood?