Brandon Webb or Roy Halladay to send your team to the playoffs?

With the way the Phillies rotation has started, give me either and I'd be overjoyed. I'd take Halladay based on the fact that every now and then (not often) Webb seems to get lit up for a lot of runs. Roy Halladay is just flat out consistent. So consistent, you don't hear about him enough because all he does is win. Good enough by me!

Roy Halladay

Webb is a great pitcher but i would pick Halladay over Webb in a hearth beat

Halladay. He is the only pitcher left that can consistenly pitch a complete game and it seems like the days of injury concerns are over.

Halladay is a great pitcher and I would take him any day.

Roy halladay. more dominant pitcher.

Halladay for sure. Webb is hurt and he should be one of the dbacks best players this year. I am disappointed in him

I would also take Halladay. He is one fantastic pitcher.

That's an interesting question considering that while both pitchers are among the best in baseball, neither have managed to take either of their teams to the playoffs. You want me to choose a pitcher to take me to the playoffs, I'll take one with real playoff experience. Give me Beckett, Santana or Sabathia.

Roy Halladay. when he's healthy, he's the best pitcher in baseball.