Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

thoughts on 'adoption' reform?

Now, its no secret that a lot of folks here have issues with adoption, and its no secret that there are major issues with the way adoption is carried out. Coercion, paying for babies, identity tampering, etc. I was wondering if anyone had put any hard thought into what reforms should be made, and what changes should be made. I am coming from a stand point where some alternate guardianships are needed for whatever reason. So, What are the top 5 things that should be changed to make adoption better? Do you think they can be achieved through education and activism, or do you think it would require complete government originated overhaul? I am curious to see what people's ideas are. As for me, I am going to go with...

1. Openness. No adoptive parents should be allowed to decide if they should tell their child they were adopted or not. They should be required to tell the child they were adopted, and if they child wants to know then the situation surrounding their adoption.

2. The child's name not be changed unless it by their own choice later in life. Their birth parent's names be available if the birth parents are willing to be contacted, and a medical history with ethnic heritage should they not be.

3. Counciling for mothers considering giving up their children before they make the choice by unbiased professionals. Easy access to information about any financial aid programs, support groups, etc that might be available to them if they are considering due to a financial situation.

4. Enforcement of open adoptions. Any signed document promising visits, photos, letters, etc be legally binding, and breakable only by proof of abuse or endangerment. However, I feel that if the natural parent consistently fails to keep appointments, etc, then it should be revisited for the emotional welfare of the child.

5. No more for profit adoption agencies. Yes, financial security should be a factor in placements, but not the only one. More follow up visits after adoption, and therapy available for adoptees who feel they would benefit from it.

I think that with public education the first two are possible, the second two would need radical government interference, but that the last is almost impossible - even if its taken over by the government, people want to make money off of what they could. Maybe some kind of system where adoption fees went into charities to help underprivileged parents keep their kids...

any thoughts?

Update:

Mnemosyne - thats actually one of the reasons I think that alternate guardianship is needed, some people just don't want kids. Its been my experience that people who grow up knowing they were adopted are better off emotionally then people who have it sprung on them as adults. Its a little like being lied to your whole life, which adds trust issues to any abandonment issues some adoptees feel.

Also, unbiased counciling isn't the same as pressuring women not to have abortions, its allowing the woman an unbiased platform to discuss her options, someone to talk to who she doesn't feel is judging her. I think a lot of women who have abortions would benefit from counciling also - not because they shouldn't have them, but because its a difficult choice and a life changing thing that few people are equiped to deal with on their own - just like adoption. I am actually pro-adoption and a happy adoptee - but I think the system needs some work so people aren't victimized.

6 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Need to start a nonprofit organization with a strong agenda for change and to overpower NCFA.

    The current adoption industry may need to be taken down before quality change will happen.

  • 1 decade ago

    1) No falsified documents. A Certificate of Adoption can be just as recognized as a legal document as A Certificate of Birth. There should be no reason to create fraud of one document when a separate and different document can be just as easily recognized as legal and bounding.

    2)No pre-birth matching or surrendering a child at birth. Adoption should not even be allowed to be presented until AFTER a mother has given birth and tried parenting first. It should be illegal for a woman to have any contact whatsoever with an adoption agency or p-aparents, while she is pregnant or within the first couple months after she has given birth.

    3) Equal amount of money and support placed into keeping mother and child together as is dedicated to separating them through adoption. Can you imagine how many families could be saved if all the adoption grants and credits were instead reverted into family preservation?

    4)Profits from adoption made illegal, without exception. If there was no profit to be made there would be a drastic change in the coercion and manipulation that exists to convince mothers to give up their children

    5) Demolish, execute, and completly erase the NCFA and their counterparts. Why in the hell do we need such a powerful body that fights for more adoptions when it should serve a better purpose to have an equally strong force fighting to help mothers keep and raise their children.

  • 1 decade ago

    All this was attempted in the late 1970s/early 1980s (Model Adoption Act 1980) but guess who put a stop to it all?

    Yep, the adoption agencies (Gladney et al) and industry joined forces to prevent change so, as a result, the rest of the civilized world moved forward and made adoption more humane whilst the USA has lagged WAY behind because the 'industry' there is all about self-preservation and 'free enterprise'

    Pfffftttt

    Source(s): The NCFA was formed to prevent adoption reform and maintain the status quo
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    7. Stop lying on official documents (IOW, the birth certificate stays intact, and available to the adoptee AT ALL AGES).

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    6. No pre-birth matching. All options are explored and revisited as appropriate with a professional counselor, parenting, kinship parenting, abortion, adoption.

  • 1 decade ago

    All this talk about adoption and there's one thing no one is saying. Either none of you have thought of it or none of you want to acknowledge it.

    Sometimes birth mothers want nothing more to do with the children they are giving up!!

    [And please don't give me the crap about how she's a whore or should take responsibility, yada, yada. Okay we all know that at the end of the day none of this would be happening if we live in a perfect world.]

    But the fact of the matter is, it is happening. Giving a child information about a parent who never wanted them and probably never will isn't exactly productive. Personally I feel like when they are old enough and the adoptive parents feel they are mature enough they should be told. Telling a child that your mommy and daddy aren't actually your mommy and daddy and that your real mommy didn't want you isn't the best bedtime story.

    And this is just one example. Sometimes these kids are adopted from foster homes where they originally came from crackhead parents, or abuse or whatever. Do you really think it's good that a child knows that so early in life (talking about the ones who would be too young to remember the bad stuff)? Hell of a burden for one so young to bear.

    As for everything else you mentioned, like counseling. It all sounds like the same thing that pro-lifers try to push on women considering abortion. The choice is hard enough, do they really need someone subtly telling them what they're doing is wrong?? And what's so wrong with a name change. New family, new life. Why would the child have the surname (if a newborn I'm assuming the birth parents haven't named it) of the person who gave him/her away?

    At the end of the day is adoption THAT horrible? I mean considering how bad a child's life can be, growing up in a loving stable household isn't that bad at all. Yes it's hurtful when you initially find out the truth. But a well rounded, adjusted adult will eventually accept it and move on. I would rather see children adopted and not told the truth until they're 18 than see them hopping from foster home to foster home abused and neglected. Or stuck with a parent who never wanted them and they are, again, abused and neglected.

    Oh, and I agree that there should be no more profit agencies. I don't agree with people making money off of something like this.

    Source(s): Victim of child abandonment. Almost lost in the system but I was adopted.
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.