Battle of the Comeback Albums!?

the only one of these I've heard all the way through is Death Magnetic, and I don't like to call it a "comeback". Metallica after the black album was just a different band, Magnetic is kind of a mash between old and new Metallica. I'd say 8.5/10

I do like AC/DC's "Rock and Roll Train" and Alice's "Check My Brain", I'd give both a 7/10

Guns N Roses should have stayed dead. 0.5/10

Slayer and Kiss, I have heard nothing at all from either album. I've never been a huge Kiss fan, and even less familiar with the work of Slayer. ?/10 for both

Black Ice-AC/DC 3/10

Chinese Democracy-Guns N' Roses 10/10

Death Magnetic-Metallica 5/10

Black Gives Way to Blue-Alice in Chains 7/10

World Painted Blood-Slayer 3/10

Sonic Boom-Kiss 4/10

Chinese Democracy is really in a league of it's own. It's the only album out of these 6 that will be considered a classic after 10 years. Even though right now people desperately want to hate it.

Black Ice - AC/DC (10)

Chinese Democracy - Guns N Roses (8)

Death Magnetic - Metallica (5)

Black Gives Way to Blue - Alice in Chains (5)

World Painted Blood - Slayer (5)

Sonic Boom - Kiss (10)

Black Ice 7/10

Chinese Democracy 1/10

Death Magnetic 8/10

Black Gives Way to Blue 9/10

World Painted Blood 9/10

Sonic Boom 7/10

OK for me it would be in this order:

AC/DC ~ Black Ice

Death Magnetic ~ Metallica

Black Gives Way To Blue ~ Alice In Chains

World Painted Blood ~ Slayer

Sonic Boom ~ Kiss

Chinese Democracy ~ Guns 'N' Roses

Black Ice - AC/DC-7

Chinese Democracy - Guns N Roses-1

Death Magnetic - Metallica-5

Black Gives Way to Blue - Alice in Chains-9

World Painted Blood - Slayer-7

Sonic Boom - Kiss-4

I have four out of these six so I'll answer thouse

black ice 8 if you don't like back in black you won't like this either

Chinese democracy 9.1 it's good just not real gnr

death magnetic 9. As I hve said before this album was just like metallics taking a thrash shot but it didn't sink fully in yet

sonic boom!!!!! 1000 it's good old kiss music KISS!!!!!!!!!!

I'm putting my own recommendations too

saints of Los Angelas crüe

the devil you know heaven and hell

revalation journey and

the stay hungry re realease by twisted sister!!!

black ice- 7

chinese democracy- 1, its not even GNR if you ask me

death magnetic- 8

black gives way to blue- 8

world painted blood- 7

sonic boom-8

edit: what i find funny you dick head is that someone cant express their opinion about how they feel. the new guns n roses (cough cough axl and friends) makes shitty music, get over yourself kid

and yes i do know every song, every member and every album of the REAL GUNS N ROSES not the **** that is put out now i could care less about axl and company

I give Chinese Democracy a 7/10

i have to disagree with you cruehead62. shes the #1 fan (although i would also disagree with that since i am :P) so shes confident enough and knows them enough to make decisions like that about the things they do. she says what she thinks and doesnt pretend cause that would be a step too close to being a poser. its like saying that if you love someone you should lick their feet and pretend to like every single thing they do. people make mistakes, and people do things that arent so good... and for all i know, axl is as human as anyone else.

wow my music's on shuffle and human being just started playing, which i know isnt really by them, but still :P