Is this diamond a good deal?

I would pass on the first diamond that has SI-2 for clarity.

The 2nd diamond, if it is an eye-clean SI-1, sounds good.

Also, do you have any Isee2 or GEMEX data as a measure of light performance?

http://www.goodoldgold.com/content.php?c=48

http://www.goodoldgold.com/Technologies/Brilliance...

*

*

*

Price: $3,828 If the SI2 diamond is eye clean i.e., you cannot see visable inclusions from 8 to 10 inches then this might be a good deal. It’s excellent that it is a certified diamond. Also if you are obtaining this ring where you have a 30 day return policy then you can always review the ring yourself first and decide what you want to do.

Price: $4,300 This also looks like a decent price. But again if you have a supplier who will give you a return benefit privilege then you can review this diamond visually before making a permanent commitment.

Good Luck!

I agree with the first answer. I would look at anything below SI1 clarity. I would say those are excellent prices, but does it include the setting as well or just the loose diamond? I would definitely go with the second diamonds. It will sparkle more and is more well proportioned.