Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
can a police officer assaulted me when i say no to reg and license?
i got pulled over and accused for going 75mph in a 55 zone and i was shocked when he said this to me. i told him i was not driving that speed limit and he told me on the other road that i was driving past 50 mph on a 45 zone. he started accusing me for speeding on the other roads too and he caught me on the radar. he ask for my license and reg and i said no why. i guessed he got mad and opened the door and begin to grab my left arm and i was aware what he was about to do cuz i never got assaulted before. he took my left arm and twisted and told me to get out of car. i was still on my seatbelt and i cant get out of the car cuz im a big guy and he draged me out of the car. there was pain around my left arm as he twisted it harder and harder. i believe that was an assault and i should file a complaint
8 Answers
- dwmatty19Lv 51 decade agoFavorite Answer
Driving is a privilege and not a right. State vehicle code laws allows an officer to stop a driver suspected of committing a traffic violation. That same vehicle code authorizes the officer to ask for your drivers license, registration and proof of insurance. That same vehicle code requires you, the driver, to produce those documents on request of the officer. (Whether you agree or not with having committed a traffic violation.) Your failure to do so is a violation itself, and depending on the laws of your particular state, is also a criminal offense. You do not have the right or option to refuse to produce those documents. As such, and depending on the laws of your state, the officer has the right to arrest you for failing to comply.
Word of wisdom for you. If you disagree with an officer as to a traffic violation, follow the rules and produce the documents. Your disagreement with the officer should take place in court where you have requested a hearing to contest it, and not at the time of the traffic stop. Know the law, and the legal actions an officer can take, before making accusations of police misconduct.
- KC V ™Lv 71 decade ago
Was there excessive force...I don't know because I'm not certain you're telling the whole story here.
The officer should explain to you why you are being stopped and ask for your license, registration, and proof of insurance.
If you read your state law you will realize that your license is actually the property of the state and you are required to provide the license to an authorized representative upon demand.
Most people honestly don't realize, when speeding, just how fast they are going at times. It's easy to go faster than what you often realize.
The thing to remember, however, is take your defense to court and fight the ticket in court...not with the officer on the street.
Source(s): Police Officer +30 years - GRUMPYLv 71 decade ago
You broke the law is the first thing. Regardless of how small of a crime/infraction the law IS the law. This does apply in basically ALL of the United States. BUT if you are stopped and asked for your license and registration you MUST comply. If you do not as in you refuse the officer does have the right to arrest you. And even if he does as this officer allegedly did, he does have the right to grab you and pull you out of the vehicle. ASSAULTED you? I have to beg to differ with this version. He grabbed you by the arm and was pulling (forcing) you out of the vehicle. You already showed RESISTANCE by refusing to give him your license and registration. As such he is justified is using force. NOW if he had peppered sprayed you or hit you with his baton, then I might look at this incident differently. BUT to just open your door and force you out, sorry. I would suggest that you comply in the future, and from your attitude I already know there WILL BE more involvements with the law.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
You are required to show the drivers license, registration, and proof of insurance. Refusing to do so gets you arrested. The officer used one of many "pain compliant" holds designed to compel your compliance to his order to get out of the car.
You were not assaulted. You will be fortunate if you are not charged with resisting arrest.
You managed to go from a simple misdemeanor speeding ticket, which would have resulted in a fine, to possibly being charged with a felony crime, which could cost you time in prison.
You made a mountain out of a mole hill. I hope you have a good lawyer.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- GrahamLv 41 decade ago
Since I do not know where you live and thus you're local laws, I can't be 100% sure. But that definitely sounds like unnecessary force (unnecessary force is the use of force when there is no justification or reason) and, if you're telling the truth and have evidence (like the dashboard cam), you could probably file a successful complaint.
This is assuming a few things: like i said, that you have evidence. That he physically pulled you out without warning you first. That you were not being exceedingly stubborn or antagonizing. That he did not ask several times for you to exit your vehicle.
- 1 decade ago
You don't have any choice when driving but to hand over your license and try to fight it and win in court.
But when you refused, he then had grounds, legal basis to arrest you. When you physically didn't comply with his verbal and physical direction and control you then were resisting arrest.
You need to understand that any complaint in this situation (if they even ALLOW you to FILE one) would quickly end in exonerating the officer finding that he acted properly.
A better effort at obeying traffic laws and taking responsibility for your own behavior and errors would pay off greatly for you in life.
This incident is a good indication that you're headed towards life as a loser and possible future inmate. Best of luck in turning your direction around 180 degrees.
Source(s): 16 year city cop - Lori MLv 41 decade ago
You don't have a leg to stand on you can't file charges and if you try to you will be laughed out of court! You were not complying with his request. He clocked you doing over the legal speed limit the best thing you could have done for yourself was be nice and comply with what was asked of you! That is 20 miles over the legal limit and considered reckless driving in most states punishable by revoking your license. Yep he did what he had to do cause you wouldn't do what you were suppose to do!
Aww 8 thumbs down well that just hurt my little feelings! Not! Bum probably was being mouthy he isn't very intelligent sounding in his post!
Source(s): Me, Criminal Justice Honors Student - 1 decade ago
you should file a complaint and immediately talk to an attorney an officer is supposed to ask you to step out of your car.