Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Stacie! asked in Family & RelationshipsWeddings · 1 decade ago

Who would typically be maid of honor in this situation?

I'm trying to decide between my best friend and my sister. My sister is like a best friend. And my best friend has been through EVERYTHING with me. And I mean everything.

I'm not sure which one to choose, and I was wondering what typical tradition was.

Also, when I was talking about this with my grandma (she's stepping in as mommy since my mom died when I was eight), my grandma mentioned the fact that my sister is still in high school. Would that be a concern?

12 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I was in the same situation. My only sister is only 16 and my best friend has been around even longer than that. I chose my best friend as my maid of honor for several reasons:

    - MOH is traditionally involved in party planning (showers, bachelorette party) that is beyond a 16-year old's capabilities and resources

    - MOH traditionally signs the marriage license as a witness, and to do so she must be 18 (in the US)

    - MOH may be asked to help with special tasks and errands that a teenager would not have the time or resources to accomplish

    - MOH typically acts as "head bridesmaid" in that she helps keep the other girls organized and on schedule and I felt more comfortable giving this responsibility to an adult

    The above reasons are only traditions though, and you're more than welcome to make your sister your maid of honor and ask another adult bridesmaid to stand in where necessary for the stuff that's out of your sister's abilities. Its completely up to you, I just wanted to share my thought process.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    Well to be sincere I watching at it from a further bridesmaid standpoint, I might be disenchanted when you selected anyone to be the MOH after which she did not ought to do some thing. I suppose it's special that you just wish to honor your actual first-rate buddy, who gave up the ghost. However I might seem intently at who you will be alienating which are your peers now who would possibly believe just about you after which get disenchanted approximately this option. All that mentioned, it's your enormous day. You must now not ought to settle. If you wish to honor your buddy this fashion, do it. You would possibly wish to provide an explanation for for your different peers and inform them how a lot it fairly manner. If they're truly peers they are going to realize, they could also be a bit of flustered or harm, however they are going to recover from it. Enjoy your enormous day and check out to cherish and honor your new friendships as good. Besides your new hubby shall be your lifelong BFF!

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Your Maid of Honor is the one who signs your marriage license, among other duties. If are in the US and your sister is not yet 18, she cannot sign a legally binding document. If this is the case, your best friend should be your MOH.

    Other duties that traditionaly fall to the MOH: planning the bridal shower, bacholorette parties, coordinating and passing information to the rest of the wedding party - this is a lot to put on the plate of a girl in high school!

    If they are the same age, ask your sister to be your MOH.

  • Poodie
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    You should choose them both as they are equally important to you. If you would like your maid of honor to sign your license, then your best friend can do that. All a maid of honor needs to do is really be in support of the bride and groom's union. You want people who are special to you there.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    If your sister is fairly on the young side, then I think it'd be okay to chose your best friend.

    Usually its an honor given to a sister, if you have one...but it all comes down to who you're closer to. Its understandable that your friend is closer to you in age and therefore has been there through everything that's happened throughout your life.

    Remember, typically, the maid of honor also has a hand in planning the bridal shower and the bacholorette party, as well as making speeches at the rehearsal dinner and/or wedding.

    I have not been as close to my sister as of recently and I've chosen my best friend as my maid of honor.

  • 1 decade ago

    you don't have to have one. I'm sure your sister would be offended if she weren't picked, but your friend would understand if you chose your sister. it's too much of a mess to deal with all that, just call them all attendants and be done with it. I don't have a MOH, just 3 close friends. I don't want anyone throwing me a bachelorette or making a speech about me at the wedding, how embarassing.

  • 1 decade ago

    Maid of honor is a BIG responsibility. If your sister can handle it, then choose her. (My best friend is having me AND her other best friend be CO maid of honors at her wedding, you can always choose both). Good luck! :)

  • 1 decade ago

    well if your sister has the capacity to be a maid of honor yes if not then your bestfriend

  • 1 decade ago

    You can have two maid of honors if you want! I've been to a lot of weddings lately where both a sister and friend are "coMOH." Tradition is to pick your sister, but since she is in high school she may not fully understand the responsibilities. It's also expensive to be MOH, will your parents be paying for her or is she paying for everything on her own? That's important to consider too. Remember, it's not just a fun title. It's a job. You sister may think she wants to be MOH, but in the end she may find it more fun to just be a bridesmaid.

  • 1 decade ago

    They are both dear to you, I would never leave out my sister, just have both. There is no reason for either one or you to be unhappy here!

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.