Barry Bonds, Cal Ripken or Mike Piazza?

Ripken. Solid defensive player, solid bat, leader in the clubhouse, class act on and off the field, doesn't get injured.

certain. properly, probable certain. Larkin suffers from under no circumstances being the spotlight shortstop in baseball. For a lengthy time period, Ozzie replaced into the protecting wizard and Ripken, the enormous slugger. Larkin did win the 1995 NL MVP, yet at the same time Cal replaced into passing Gehrig and getting each and each of the headlines. and then, in basic terms as Ozzie retired and Cal's enormous quest replaced into over, alongside got here the triumvirate -- Garciaparra, Jeter, and the tsunami of Alex Rodriguez. Larkin under no circumstances had an significant window in which to be the common of shortstopping in baseball. And which will probable value his candidacy a year or 2, yet he could get in without too a lot delay.

It's a disgrace to Ripken's name to mention those other two in the same sentence. Bonds was a "juicer", and a total jerk. All Piazza could do was hit. He was a liabilty on defense. Ripken was "clean", could hit and play defense. No contest.

Sarge

No brainer! Cal Ripken Jr. Upstanding guy, clean player and I would know that we would win a world series as well.

Ripken, easily. If you knew you wouldn't need a SS fr the next 15 years, you'd be golden

MIKE PIAZZA! im a huge mets fan so i guess im kinda biased but i would still take piazza... in his prime he was good defensively and even better offensively... Catcher is the hardest position to find a good 2 way player and piazza was it. Ther are plenty of good fielding and hitting outfielders and shortstops, but not many catcher's... piazza had swagger and new york loves him... LETS GO METS

I don't know why, but I just really like Cal Ripken.

Barry Bonds. Even without steroids, he could still hit homeruns easily. Most feared hitter in baseball.

Why would anyone want Bonds.

He is a disgrace to baseball.

I would without hesitation go with Ripken.

Rookie of the year, MVP and just did his job day after day. He also provided us with one of the greatest events in sports history, the night he broke Lou Gehrig's record.