Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

If Black American culture exists, why is it so taboo to say that someone "acts Black" or "acts White"?

Update:

How is it possible for a culture to exist, but then be "impossible" for someone to act like they are of that culture?

Its like saying French people exist and that there is a definite French culture, but it's impossible to act French.

Update 2:

For the purposes of this question, I mean Black Americans, not ALL Blacks across the planet.

Update 3:

Gyasi you're turning this into an issue of semantics when it's not, and you're not coming up with anything valid to say. Stop hiding behind rhetoric and either answer the question or shut up.

Update 4:

once again, to all the ppl here when I say "act Black" I mean Black American or African American. This question doesn't pertain to Blacks in the West Indies, Latin America or Africa.

Update 5:

Ok Gyasi, whatever. In the interest of proper semantics I'll re-word the question.

Why is it so taboo or politically incorrect to say that someone acts like an African American person or a White person if African American culture does exist.

Update 6:

The fact that everyone is different doesn't make my question invalid. Yes, individuals are, by the very nature of the term, individual. But despite that there are cultural similarities which manifest themselves in how we socialise, how we communicate and what our values are and it is on THAT basis that I'm asking whether or not it's possible for someone to "act Black" or "act White". I'm not talking about minute, unique personal traits like how you like your coffee or whether or not you can dance. I'm talking about more overt traits that you can observe without knowing an individual personally such as speech, dialect, dress, hairstyle, etc.

Update 7:

Gyasi, you're taking it as if I'm saying people of a particular ethnicity act exactly the same and I'm not. I specifically said I wasn't talking about personality.

I'm talking in GENERAL terms like Accent, Dialect, Dress, etc.

Update 8:

It has nothing to do with people actually ACTING the same, it's about people sharing specific cultural commonalities that are generally not found in other cultures.

Update 9:

Dude, whatever. You never answered my question so think whatever you want, it really don't matter.

12 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Some aspects of Black culture can be negative (ghetto life, possible gang activity, illegitimate children, etc.), so some people might not want to possibly be associated with the negative aspects of acting Black.

  • 1 decade ago

    This might've been true during Jim Crow, but integration has certainly blurred the lines. A lot of elements people claim as "Black culture" have been absorbed into the mainstream(and mostly White) American culture.

  • ?
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    You can't "act" like a skin color, nor can you "act" like an ethnicity. To insinuate that such would even be conceivable is nonsensical jargon that exceeds any sound reasoning.

    -----------

    Alright then, why don't you explain to me how you can act like an ethnicity or a skin color? Not like a PERSON of that ethnicity or of that race, but like that race or ethnicity. If you can do that and somehow manage to make sense, I will tip my hat to you.

    ----------

    On another note: I did notice that you said "Black American culture", but what you're saying and what the questions says don't follow up. Because the term "black" is a broad sweeping statement that does not cover only black Americans, it simply isn't fair to say that someone acts black or can even act black.

    ------

    I answered your question perfectly fine and YOU aren't coming up with any valid rebuttal. You should stop hiding behind flawed logic because you aren't capable of critical thinking.

    -------

    It doesn't matter who the term "black" is addressed to when it can mean just about anything. By the way, you can't "act" like a Black American seeing how every single person is different. Once again, flawed logic.

    -------

    It's wrong to say that because every single person is different. Not all black people act the same way as you seem to think. The "culture" they come from really doesn't make a difference if you take into account that every single person has a unique personality.

    -----

    You're still not understanding that no matter what, you CANNOT act like a skin color. You can act like a stereotype of the person you're portraying (because every single person of that stereotype would act a certain way because it isn't reality), but you can't act like the actual version of the people you're talking about. The differences between people are the very reason WHY it isn't possible to act like a race or an ethnicity, because not everyone is the same. To say that you could "act black" only implies that all black people are exactly the same. In fact, it would be like saying you can act like a "German". Well what defines a German? A native or inhabitant of Germany.

    Source(s): At this point it really doesn't matter what you're talking about because you're not even disproving any of what I said. You're trying to make a sweeping statement by separating personality from the people. Just because you won't admit that your generalizations are wrong, doesn't make you right. How can it not have anything to do with acting the same when this question is based on acting like something? Now you're not even making sense.
  • 1 decade ago

    heh it's context, look at it like a verbal weapon that the "other" side uses on their own. some black folks use it on other black folks when they think someone is acting better than the rest of them and white folks use it when they think someone is generally lower class or uses terms like "baby daddy". i have yet to see a black fella say another black guy acts black, or a white fella acts white

    it's taboo 'cause it's generally used as an insult, an insult based on race

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    because blacks can be from all over the world

    not just america

    and usually when someone says "acting a race" it usually means the stereotypes that come with that race

    not the culture

  • 1 decade ago

    BRILLIANT QUESTION!!! I'm very impressed you came up with this.

    Firstly we have to establish what is black culture.

    Secondly what is white culture.

    Thirdly if there are behaviours that are characteristic of either culture. If not the question is irrelevant.

    If yes it is indeed hypocritical the blacks want their children to be brought up, understand and 'exercise'? black culture, yet affirm there is no such thing as acting white or acting black.

  • 1 decade ago

    Because 'Black', in this day and age is a very wide term.Meaning, ever black person in every different culture around the world ...is different.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    A BLACK PERSON acts black has are culture and acting white is liking American eagle etc

  • 1 decade ago

    it shows black people have managed to develop a seperate culture despite being apart of the same sociaty of over 200 years which points to the fact that black people are ostrisized

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Because Black is not a culture its a color..

    I would agree with you if they said African American culture, but they don't.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.