Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Boss told me 'all Italians are catholic' and I got offended...was I wrong to be offended?
My boss can sometimes say things that are out of line, and today she said something that really offended me. She had said 'All Italians are Catholic.' She knows that I am part Italian(Grandfather's family is Italian) and when she realized that it had offended me she just kept pressing it...
She kept saying that the pope is in Italy, therefor when I die I'll go to heaven and I was born catholic just because of my roots. I do not even believe in Jesus or the christian/catholic god or heaven or hell or satan.
So was I wrong to get offended by this or am I wrong all together? I'm feeling rather confused.
tropical beauty: Of course I know the Vatican is in Italy -.- But when you think about it, it's pretty ridiculous to say someone is something because of something out of their control(ie all Italians are catholic because the pope resides in Italy).
A: That's great that you are now speaking for all Italians, I'm so happy that you have such a high social status that you know everyone hates Italian-Americans. Oh, and if you read the details of my question, you would have noticed that I had said 'part Italian' I did not say 'I am Italian' although my Grandfather's family is and my cousins still live there. To top that off, I am not American, I am Canadian. That border is there for a reason(no offense to Americans).
21 Answers
- ?Lv 59 years agoFavorite Answer
It could be worse. My Italian friends are always being assumed to be Mob. Moron bosses are part of the territory and unfortunately they have all the power. When conversations take a crazy turn, try to escape as quickly as possible and say as little as possible.
You have every right on an emotional level to be offended. It just won't do you a bit of good and may cost you everything. Bottle it up and then screen "The Office" at home, both versions, the American and British, so you can see how common these jerks are.
- ?Lv 69 years ago
It was an ignorant thing for her to say, but offence is a choice you must make. You could always just blow it off as the ignorance that it is. Some people think all Mexicans are Catholic, too. While it is true that both of these cultures have a very rich Catholic history, it is also true that there is no such thing as 100% when it comes to people and their ways. You might have mentioned to her that even though the Pope resides in Italy, he is a German, and Germany is the most secularized nation on earth.
- GiulyLv 75 years ago
I'm Italian from ITALY and I'm wondering where is the offence. MOST Italians are catholic, not all...where is the offence?
I'm not offended by your boss...geez, there are so many people who really insult Italians saying our men are all psycho mama boys and us women poor idiots who stay in the kitchen to cook while our men cheat on us, and a lot of other disgusting lies about us, but this...I don't understand you.
Saluti dall'Italia, il paese dove la maggioranza degli italiani va tutte le domeniche a messa.
- Bobby JimLv 79 years ago
Though the Roman Catholic Faith is the "official" religion of Italy, not all Italians are Roman Catholic. Some are even atheists. Don't be offended by the ignorance of anyone. It's truly a teaching moment.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous5 years ago
you're starting to be indignant because you're taking the grievance as a own attack. interior the case you defined, it isn't an attack, that is a training challenge. Now it might want to be the guy training might want to opt to study somewhat extra finesse in drawing near human beings, yet even then, the purpose is that can help you you do properly, no longer degrade you. it might want to also be a situtation the position in case you don't know a thanks to do your job ideal, then that man or woman or the crew is penalized, so that is likewise to their income that you be shown the brilliant thanks to do issues. check out it this way. If the grievance, is meant that can help you you boost, then it isn't an attack and is meant on your betterment. don't be so protecting. If the grievance, does no longer some thing that can help you you boost, then that is a own attack--flow ahead and be indignant.
- 9 years ago
Your boss seems to be a creep, going around saying things about Italians all being Catholics is rather rude. Your only suppose to say stuff like that if your behind a computer and no body can touch you.
- OzNanaLv 79 years ago
So rather than getting offended, you need to say, 'Well I'm of Italian descent, and I'm not a catholic'.
THat's all. You don't need to explain further, unless you really want to. If you wanted, you can go on to say, 'Actually, I'm a [insert whatever you are]. '
- MarkLv 79 years ago
Offended? Yes. Annoyed? No. (Not all Italians ARE Catholic.) Or, to put it another way, tell her calmly that not all Italians are Catholic but don't go running to H.R. to report it, unless she does this all the time and you've told her you don't appreciate it.
- ?Lv 59 years ago
Well you are only part italian and you can have only one religion so maybe your italian background did not stick out in your family. I was once a roman catholic until I realized religion is fake.
- ZasetsuLv 69 years ago
Don't let ANYONE try to formulate thoughts for you..and the best way to counter the kind of crap like this is to put one of those mysterious Mona Lisa smiles...nod your head a bit....say..."Yeah...you right"...laugh inside of your head for a second or two..then move on, and you might consider telling your boss IN WRITING that you were not comfortable discussing religion and matters of religion at your place of work.If need be, have a copy made and deliver it to HER boss....no one has the right to make you doubt your beliefs...or doubt your LACK of beliefs.