Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

She got engaged to her ex while she was still dating me!!!?

I'm going to try and keep this short. I fell in love with a girl who had a boyfriend of 4 years. She eventually left him for me. We started dating in December of 2011. As time went on, we were both in love and even talked about getting married someday. She wanted to get married before she was 23 (she's 19 now), but I told her that I wanted to get married after I had gotten my career underway, and when I was in my later 20s (I'm 20 now and in college). We had an intense physical relationship as well. She couldn't keep her hands off me and always wanted more. She even told me that she had never kissed anyone the way she kissed me. About 5 months into our relationship her ex got an a bad car wreck. He was in the hospital and she went to be there for him. After he got out, she helped take care of him because he had trouble getting around. I was mad, but she promised that there was nothing going on. Then, she told me she had to pretend to be his girl because he had mental issues and he might hurt himself on purpose. As mad as I was we continued dating. Everything was okay until April of this year, when she didn't see me as often. And when she did, it was only for like an hour unlike when she used to spend whole days with me. However, she still loved the physical stuff. A couple days ago she calls me and out of nowhere says she can't see me anymore and that she's sorry she hurt me. The next day her ex comes to my place and talks to me. He tells me that they had been dating for the past year, and that they got engaged on Feb. 24. He showed me the ring. I was devastated. I thought she was my girl but it turns out I was wrong. I was very good to her (unlike her ex who cheated on her). I sang to her, wrote poetry, and was very romantic. She told me how she loved those things about me. Why didn't she tell me anything? Why did she get engaged and not tell me? She knew he was coming to talk to me, so did she only break it off with me because she knew she was about to get caught? How could someone make promises and say they're in love and be lying the entire time? Did she get rid of me because he could give her what she wanted now (marriage) while she knew that I couldn't give her that any time soon, so she essentially took the safer bet?

-Also, he bought her a car, and bought a house and other stuff for her with the money he got from the accident. Did that play any part in it? We were together for 16 great months and it was ruined in one day. There is more to the story but that is the gist of it. Any feedback would be great.

2 Answers

Relevance
  • 8 years ago

    She probably fell back in love with him while she was taking care of him, you can't forget 4 years. The fact that he is able to offer her all this stuff only emphasized the point, because deep down almos every girl wants a guy who can take care of her and their family. He's showing that capabilty but the fact that he knew you two were still together and he came to you about the ring is weird. You should talk to the girl just in case he's trying to mess things up. Overall she sounds like a gold digger and too weak to tell the truth, if anything it's good this happened because she couldv'e left you later in life like that with a different guy

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    its pretty tragic man. but the way I see it is if u guys spent 16 months together and she was in love how can all those feelings be lost in just around a year or so. if h treates her as good as you say and he didnt shell come back.eventually. she just likes his stuff. shell.be back because hell probably.mess up again and.when that time comes you decide if u want revenge or just to push her away. dont swrat it. I know its hard but shell reliaze it when ur showing that same love to another female. btw do you mind helping me out on my question on my profile. you seem like you could help me out a lot. please thank ylu and goods luck

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.