Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Does this qualify as a poem?
Saplings bend in a storm because they must
or break, shredded, to nurture another
under the crust of the mother
with no emotion, no sense of trust.
They will or won't grow to tall trees
one day offering welcoming shade
to one wanting respite in a sheltered glade
out of the blistering heat, most pleased.
Perhaps we as a species, are saplings too
extensions of seeds dropped
having needs, that may never stop
rising above each challenge, new.
Of course I'd be glad to explain Skumpfsk.
This is perhaps only a brief journey for me, in having posted around a dozen poems, which I don't brag over. Secondly, I've never written a sonnet, but understand them.
13 Answers
- skumpfsklubLv 68 years agoFavorite Answer
It does. What question comes to my mind---rather than that posted---is how you came to stop a couplet short of a 'Petrarchan sonnetoid'. It's pretty good, as is, so I reckoned that you'd chosen to dodge the urge to perform more formally.
Why THAT question comes to mind is easy to explain: I saw (and continue to see) a sonnet here (rather, the beginnings of one, in one of the many forms called 'sonnet), and my sonnet expectation module deployed. I was not disappointed, but that module looked a bit downcast, later.
So, to keep peace in my unruly mental house, would you say a word on how&why it is that there are not two more lines in this piece?
- ?Lv 78 years ago
Kels
First of all, I admire your humility. Enough said, but great quality
seen by others but you would never admit.
You hit a home run with this one, both in content, which was pretty
and filled with imagery in such a serene manner, and your construct
was superb. Very good flow, and a keen and full of imagery rhyme
tree to compliment each line but not overtake it with too much sapidity.
Most impressive to me was your pattern on the rhymes, blended well
and this was not as easy as some might think.
Yes, this qualifies as a very good poem Kels. Some room to improve
on this project with the meters syllable count if that is important to you.
It is to me, but am not carrying as much value as I used to so long the
flow is good.
- Anonymous8 years ago
Bravo Kels. Very nice poem. An ancient American-Indian notion is analyzed here briefly. Congratulations for your ancestral characteristics.
- 8 years ago
Not bad...
It didn't have the word eyes or springtime or flowers or whatever in it, so, not bad, but...the plant and seed analogy is probably going for the norm. Try to use more bizarre or non-standard analogies. Makes ya' stand out from the crowd more and gets the same ideas across, only better.
Just an observation. But overall, very good.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- HimedalLv 58 years ago
Having needs that may never stop. That is so true. The whole poem is very good though. Well done.
- Rayven53Lv 68 years ago
GO on, tell 'em, Kels...you're not above nor below...simply aside from...formal format! :)
Was most enjoyable, love!
- 8 years ago
I thought this was an interesting read, Good morning Kels & hope u have a good weekend hugs.
- lovechildLv 78 years ago
This branch of poetry suits you ....second best. The first type I am fond of are your mystical writes. this is lovely and warm.