Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
If all cells die, what is the origin of evolution?
Interesting that I also asked this in the Biology section and I've yet to get an answer. Why?........well I think they me be a bit more intelligent. They obviously know that there is no explanation. For those that aren't so smart I'll break it down.
If all cells die that means no cell lives forever.
If no cell lives forever then how could there be an initial cell?
If there is no initial cell there is no LIFE to begin with
And Marci, I didn't realize that you believe in Scientology. Isn't this something similar to their beliefs. Aliens in volcanoes and such?
Very bad answers so far. I'm sorely disappointed.
13 Answers
- Anonymous8 years agoFavorite Answer
Reproduction, herp a derpity derptastic sandwich.
- ?Lv 78 years ago
You probably didn't get an answer in the biology section because other sections tend to ignore troll questions, not because there is no explanation.
Evolution happens to populations, not individuals.
Why would a cell need to live forever for there to be an initial cell? That's a complete non-sequiter. You essentially just said that life can't exist because no life form exists forever.
The available evidence indicates that under certain conditions, organic molecules spontaneously form. Once simple molecules form, they join and form more complex molecules. It's been done in the lab, and the longer you let the experiment run, the more complex the structures get. Given a half billion years and all the oceans in the world it probably wouldn't have taken long for the first biological structures that fit the definition of life to form. Once you have replication you can get replication errors and mutations, which are one of the bases of evolution. Once you have a population of protocells, you can have natural selection which is the other base of evolution.
Your question tells me that either you don't know the first thing about evolution and you've got some bizarre misconceptions about what it is, or you're trolling trying to make creationists look stupid. I'm not sure which it is, but apparently the biology section thinks you're a troll.
- DiesixDieLv 68 years ago
"If no cell lives forever then how could there be an initial cell?"
In what way does the lack of cellular immortality disqualify an "original cell"? You don't like any of the other answers here, mostly because your question can't be answered, because it's not a valid question. Not only is the initial assumption wrong, but, even if it wasn't, you'd still only be restating the "chicken and the egg" conundrum. It assumes a "single first cell" happened at some point.
You're not going to like any answer other than "God pointed his finger and made it happen" so why are you wasting our time?
- Maurog IVLv 78 years ago
Reproduction, variation, and natural selection (which requires death).
If you're talking about single-celled organisms, they didn't all die. In fact, you can trace every current single-celled organism to that initial spark of life you called the "first cell". If mitosis for you isn't death, that mean the initial cell is still alive and all around us :)
Of course it changed a lot since then because of variation, and most if it is dead because of natural selection, but some part of it is alive in the form of every single-celled organism around you.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- ?Lv 68 years ago
Boson Higgs theory tells us that even matter replicates and dies. Panspermia theory tells that microscopic life is everywhere in the universe, just waiting to be transported via a comet, to an opportune planet.
Evolution is that microscopic life having an environment that allows it to grow and gradually develop in various ways. Evolution happens gradually over millions of years, so its not something you'll see in a lifetime.
- ?Lv 78 years ago
What a non sequitur! Evolution operates at the population level, not the cellular level. The death of cells has nothing to do with it.
BTW, if you think that all cells die, google "HeLa".
- Anonymous8 years ago
That's like asking if my shoes cost 50 quid, why was it raining two days ago?