Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Is Angry Horse an Atheist?

I see that your perfectly reasonable question "two questions for atheists" has been reported before I'd finished answering it. This is my answer, anyway:

1) A lot of people who have been very talented inventors, artists, musicians, writers etc have also been a bit nutty in other ways. Some of the greatest composers, artists, writers etc have also been quite anti semitic, or have other odd beliefs. Being able to invent something, or do something that requires great skill doesn't mean that people with dotty religious beliefs are excluded. Talent has little to do with religious belief, on the whole. A lot of people don't like Harry Potter etc. They're entitled to their opinion, provided they don't start burning books or saying that books are evil etc. When people start banning books, it is a slippery slide to more serious acts of violence or abuse towards other groups of people. Hitler burned books.

2). What to really think of the bible. Well, it's a collection of very, very old texts, written by lots of different people, at different periods of time. Their target audience were largely uneducated, couldn't read or write themselves, and were very superstitious, because people didn't know any better at that time, and were only trying to make sense out of the world they lived in, and events that to them were inexplicable. Disease for example. We know what causes most diseases today. But they didn't then. So disease was either an act of god, or someone had put a spell on you, or it was demons, or you'd broken some religious rule.

Some people really need religion in their lives, and there's no doubt that it has and still does fulfil all sorts of social functions. But it is all invented by man. We are fallible creatures who don't always get it right. So different religious texts, different ideas about whether there's a god or gods or not, and the nature of these entities. Different ideas about the nature of god, whether gods are nasty, vengeful creatures, or kindly, loving entities. In some countries and times, gods can be all of these things. The people who liked to speculate or 'invent' these creatures liked to cover all bases. Religion is mostly about controlling people, telling them how to live their lives, what to do, who to obey, who to fight etc.

3 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    7 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    1) even more were religious. why should being atheist matter?

    2) true and true. It serves a very good purpose. Do you think we are rid of uneducated people? no. so we still need it. And you said yourself that it was written with them as the target ... implying that uneducated came before the bible ... so I don't believe anyone can blame the bible for generating such a goup. There has always been the uneducated masses and there always will be. You will always need an all inclusive means to reach out to them.

    Our emphasis should never be on eliminating religion altogether ... but rather to ensure the dominant one is compatible with modern society such that the two may coexist and the aims can be common to our goal as a species. Christian social ideals generally are in line with common human ideals ... that's why its so palatable to so many. Its not all bad. Its something we should use and look at as an advantage. without it we would not be able to sustain the general level of happiness across the board that we do.

    Some can be happy with not having purpose ... some need it to function. As long as youre a functioning member of society ... I don't care what you believe in.

  • 7 years ago

    While I applaud your desire to provide what you consider as a good answer to a question, and I also feel your frustration at spending the time to write what you think is a rational response, adding the text of the original/deleted question would have helped immensely

    As an aside, you don't seem to realize how questions and answers are deleted on Y!A - the poster can decide that they don't like the response that they are getting and delete their Q/A or some newbie or report monkey can report it since it seems like the appeals process is essentially nothing more than "I'm a minimum wage, out-sourced employee that is paid for responding to appeals, it is easier to just reject them rather than putting forth the effort to really evaluate them"

    Sorry, a bit of a rant there.

    As for your answer as posed as a question, you have put some thought into it, but you really need to think about what you are saying (yeah, I know, you could and I definitely would say the same thing about my answers....)

  • 7 years ago

    I'm not sure who Angry Horse is, but i like your quanswer

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.