Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Looking for McCoy Cookie Jars?

Ok I'm in search of McCoy cookie jars. My mom is a big collector of them. I, myself am not to bright with them even though I grew up in the same city where they were made! lol I know to be a legit jar they have to have the McCoy stamp on the bottom. I would like to know what ones are McCoy and what ones aren't. I have been looking on Ebay for them, but they are either chipped or don't have the stamp. If there is a website to go to to see what they look like and the name it would narrow my search down so I know what they are supposed to look like as in correct coloring and such. If anyone knows of some for sale that are legit, not a replica, recolored and such please let me know! Also What are things I should look for. All of my moms are in superb condition. She is in really bad health right now and it may possibly be cancerous, so I want to get her something really nice to add to her collection! (: Thanks in advance!

3 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    7 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    there are some traditional mccoys that are unmarked but once you get an eye you can tell fake from the real McCoy and yes thats why that phrase came into play ive purchased many from 2nd hand stores a library can supply you a referance book but many prices shown are high compared to availabilty the internet has created shawnee make very nice cookie jars as well and some are extremely valuable id say McCoy range between 25.00 to 75.00 on average each so if a higher price is asked id do some research and quality is always your goal always check that lid fits correctly as scammers change these alot the only one i know that McCoy dropped the ball on is an old style cookstove style that the lids were too thin and they warped when they fired its the only factory defect ive ever encountered so all other lids should fit snug look close as they valueless if altered the ones with the "cold paint" chipped or missing do not nessisarily loose value but as a selling feature you can sometimes get "bargains" by pointing this out its a rewarding hobby i collected for years and over 50 McCoys were a consolation prize for my ex as she new very well i enjoyed them it doesnt mean much to collect without someone else to enjoy them too so ive given it up but at one time my passion was great enjoy and look closely hope my tips will help

  • 7 years ago

    Here are some non McCoy cookie jars.

    Little Red Riding Hood

    Betty Boop

    Cow jumped over the moon

    Gingerbread turnabout

    smiley pigs

    Snow White

    Pooh

    McCoy only made 2 Mammies with cauliflowers and 1 has Dem Cookies show am good on the front of the dress.

    The sites have good information. . I looked this information up when someone gave me an owl McCoy cookie jar.

  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    Hmm

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.