Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Giving new employees more pay than experienced employees?
I have worked for a hospital in California for 3 years and I have 8 years of experience in my field. I just learned that new employees with less experience are being hired on for more pay than employees who have been with the hospital several years with more experience. We both do nearly the same job (the old employees have to take the time to train the newbies) and some of the old employees actually hold a higher position (team leading, supervising) and still get paid less than a new grad. My fellow employees and I are really upset and are trying to figure out how to best handle this. Does anyone know if this is illegal? How would you approach it? I cant quit right now because I am pregnant and I need the benefits for my family. Thanks.
Wanted to add that we also discovered that the new employees received emails from administration telling them not to disclose their pay to the other employees. They are fully aware that what they are doing is unethical.
10 Answers
- Anonymous1 decade agoFavorite Answer
No, it's not illegal, as long as it doesn't violate any contract that you have. If you are union, this could be something for you to discuss with them.
You are kind of in a catch-22 here. Typically, employees salaries are not supposed to be discussed with other employees. To go into HR and tell them that you know that new hire suzy is making more than you would be to admit guilt in discussing wages. However, if you saw a classified ad or recruiting ad that lists the entry level base salary as higher than your, then you might have some leverage.
And, you could always hint at it. Talk to your manager about getting a review and a pay raise. Ask for 2-5% over what the other people are making and see if they bite. Your leverage is limited as they know you will be leaving soon on maternity leave, but you *do* stil have some leverage.
Good luck to you. : )
- 1 decade ago
Unless you have a union contract the employer can pretty much do what they want when it comes down to salary. I had a similar thing happen to me at a machine shop. I was there for 2 yrs. and training new employees that were making the same amount of money as me. I ended up quiting. I now work for a unionized Co. and we have a contract that protects us from things like that from happening. Hang in there , have the baby and start looking for a better job or try to organize a union. Good Luck!
- 1 decade ago
telling new employees not to discuss salary is common practice throughout all fields. the only recourse you have is a union if you are a part of one. if not you'll have to suck it up until you have your baby. another thing to consider is benefits. perhaps the new employees don't qualify for holidays, vacations, sick time, or health insurance for a year or not at all. that saves a company lots of money. or maybe the new employees have an arrangement for a higher salary without those benefits. if all they got was their salary and no benefits the company could easily pay them more than 30% more and still be saving money. you shouldn't jump to conclusions if you don't have all the facts. also unless you have their paychecks the info you heard may not be true.
- GrrraarrrLv 51 decade ago
There is nothing illegal or unethical about this, you were hired when the market wasn't as tight. You should really consider moving to a new facility and getting a big raise, exploit the tight job market for yourself instead of kicking your can down the street and sulking. The new hires are taking advantage of a tight job market, since you have experience, you have even more leverage.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- ray of sunshineLv 41 decade ago
I'm really not sure what you can do about it. It is wrong, but I doubt it's illegal. I worked at a place for 4 years, and they were hiring in people at the same wage I was making, that I'd had to work toward for the 4 years.. not fair at all....
- MariposaLv 71 decade ago
It is not illegal. There are a couple of things you can do though. One is to talk to HR and see if the base pay for people in your job category is going to be raised. The second choice is to apply for the higher paying positions.
- fullofsugawLv 51 decade ago
Are you friendly with anyone above you? Maybe you could mention you heard about they new employee pay rate and think it is so unfair... if you want to do this the normal way documentation is key.
Source(s): http://www.ehow.com/how_1022_ask-raise.html - BIGLLv 41 decade ago
maybe they are related to someone or are good friends with the one in charge or payroll why else would they tell them not to mention it to anyone else in the work place believe it or not there are alot of screwed up employers that hire family and do **** like this we just dont know unless it slips out of someones big mouth . sad but true good luck with the case .
- Anonymous1 decade ago
It's legal, but it shows how much Management appreciates longevity. I would get a group together and have a meeting with upper management and express your displeasure.
- Caroline HLv 51 decade ago
It is not illegal - employers claim that it is how they attract better employees - it's happened to me as well.