If you had to choose between a week in the Hawaiian Islands v. Thailand, which would you choose?

Been to both.

I would go to Hawaii if I was 19 yrs old, terrific bod, looked great without makeup and had lots of money.

Went to Thailand for 2 weeks and traveled from Bangkok to Chaing Mai. It was cheap, cheap, cheap!!! Hotels were first class, food is great, always felt safe, people were nice and polite, it was easy to get around in the cities and shopping was a blast. We rode elephants, "raced" in tuk tuks, visited Wats (temples) and boated down the Mekong Delta. Great massages and foot rubs too. Ate Thousand Year old eggs and all manner of dried insects. And so much more, I also bought my prescription medicines in Bangkok for 10% of what it costs in the US.

Our next trip is Cairo but we are definitely going back to Thailand asap.

Wow. I do not usually see so much response to a question like this so quickly - - I loved Hawaii and can see the magnificence of that - I live in Thailand - every day seems to be a learning experience/adventure for me - - Hawaii is, for the most part, more physically beautiful - though of course we have that here too - and that here, the difference in culture is living and breathing, whereas in Hawaii it is in "culture centers" -

I would say this - if you come to Thailand, you can rent a van and driver fairly reasonably and get to some out of the way, off the tourist trail spots - and there are many and it is easy and safe and interesting - for the same money, you can go in a bit more luxurious style too and see and experience things that are quite different...

If you decide on Hawaii - make sure to have a group reading of Michener's book "Hawaii" - it will greatly enhance your visit and make everything more memorable and interesting. It really explains Hawaii..

How nice to have 2 good choices!! I like them both. As to the decision - the best way is this - check with the others or if you are the decision maker - flip a coin - it is not the coin that will decide the outcome, but when it is in the air, you will know which one you are hoping for - and then choose that one.

I would love to know which one you choose - - I think you can't go wrong !! Enjoy.

Thailand could be kinder on the budget but be advised that a "budget Thailand" may not meet the American standard in terms of accommodation, food, etc. You would also need to stay away from the restive south where moslem separatist groups are waging a terror-type war with Bangkok authorities.

Having said that, it would be fair to find out details about actual budgets for a Thai stay before deciding on Hawaii; Phuket Island or thereabout; even Hua Hin the less popular of the two are irresistible Far East-type destinations for any visitor - strange language, barely understandable english, wide variety of local and foreign food and of course loads of seaside- and ocean-related activities. Hawaii would be 'familiar' for Americans.

I believe Hawaii is unique on its own and will offer "lifetime memories" to just about anyone given the right circumstances and appropriate activity.

If I had to choose? Thailand.

I have the same feeling as twelve and it makes me very sad to hear(read) some people focusing only seedy side of the Kingdom.

Well it's not fair to compare Hawaii with Thailand as Thailand is a country and Hawaii is an island/state. "Hawaii or Samui" question can be answerable more comfortably. If you only have one week for your lifetime vacation, I would say Hawaii will be the place. It is almost perfectly organized for holiday makers like Disney World. You can enjoy beautiful beach, ocean, clear sky, bit of Polynesian culture, all in a week without culture-shock. Thailand, you cannot enjoy this rich Kingdom in a week. Keep Thailand for your next lifetime vacation. Aloha!

No question---come to Thailand for a great time and much less expensive. So much to see and do and shopping is unbelievable. The night life is world famous and the people are friendly and helpful. Hawaii for a tourist is like Disneyland...All plastic and created to take your money. I would never go to Hawaii and I live in Thailand.

Hawaiian Islands. Learn about vulcanoes and island life. Great! Plus taking children to Thailand could be very Strenous, for the adults at least in Hawaii you could relax and have some time out too!

Thailand for sure

Hawaii is part of the USA so our culture kinda bleeds over to it somewhat. you will find blonde haird blue eyed girls in designer clothes being prissy in Hawaii because they moved from their daddys big estate in the midwest or east coast to Hawaii because Hawaii is where the cool people go.

for sure go to Thailand. the culture there is just as old as Hawaii's native culture but they have much of their historical architecture in tact because they werent colonized, forced off their land, raped, and killed on sugar plantations (atleast as much).

also Buddhist temples are beautiful. if you only see them once in your life you will never forget them. thai food is also amazing and if its made by a person whos family has been cooking that same recipe for generations its damn near perfect.

true Thailand may have a large poverty region but if you stick to cities and the are just outside them. like go to Bangkok and see the city then leave the bigger city to the outskirts and see the countryside.

it must be beautiful there becasue Geddy Lee wrote a song about it.

another perk is the women!!

I have been to both places, having been in the Navy and got to see the world. Hawaii is okay, especially if the government is paying for it. Personally I wouldn't spend the money needed to go back. Thailand is so much better and less expensive when you get there. You'll love that place I promise you. Hawaii is a tourist trap and you'll see all you can see pretty much the first day. Thailand is a different culture and I stayed there for 4 days and still had tons I still wanted to see. Take my advice, go to Thailand.

Thailand

I really hate when people say Thailand is for sex. That's bullshit. Yeah, there's hookers there, but guess what, I lived in Hawaii and they have just as many per capita as Thailand. In fact, they roam the lobby's and bars of the hotels looking for clients.

For people who see Thailand so superficially, go to Hawaii. I'd prefer if the tourist left Thailand alone, frankly. But don't fool yourself into think Hawaii is more wholesome that Thailand. It's simply not true.

Also, the jet lag when going to and from Asia can be pretty brutal. Not nearly as bad as Hawaii.