Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Theresa asked in Pregnancy & ParentingAdoption · 1 decade ago

A secret family member – how would you feel?

I’m curious how people would feel if they were contacted by someone claiming to be a relative who was surrendered for adoption?

How would you feel to find out about an older sibling you never knew of?

Or, how would you feel to find out your brother or sister had a child that was placed for adoption and you never knew about them?

Would you want to know them? How would you feel about them contacting you? What would you think about them being kept a secret all these years?

I can share a story; many years ago on an adoptee group I belonged to, I was emailed by someone who was looking for her natural father. He had the same name as my adoptive dad. Unfortunately it wasn’t a match. I would have been thrilled to know my dad’s daughter, but really sad and upset that she had been kept a secret from me.

How would you feel? Or, has this happened to you?

15 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I would be thrilled and hope that the person would want to have a familial relationship. I would definitely think of the person in terms of the actual position in the family which he or she held by nature. I would be sad about the time we lost.

    My entire extended natural family sees me and treats me as an actual family member, not just a friend. I see them the same way. There is always room for both one's adoptive and natural family members in one's heart. Reuniting does not negate or decrease the familial relationship formed with one's adoptive family. If that relationship is poor or non-existent, it is a caused by an unstable condition that existed prior to reunion with the natural family.

    Source(s): My experience as a reunited adopted person.
  • 1 decade ago

    To be honest, I would probably not believe them and think it was some type of a scam until they showed me some proof. That's just the way I am about everything.

    Ironically though, this happened to my husband when he was a teenager. Apparently, my MIL had a child many years before she met my FIL. I'm not sure I understand the full story of what happened but basically the bio father took full custody of the child with my MIL not having any contact with the child at all.

    One day out of the blue, my MIL received a phone call from the now adult daughter and she wanted to visit. My MIL was put in the difficult situation of having to tell her son (my husband) that he was not the only child that he thought he was all those years and that he had a sister. He was excited at first but after meeting her a few times, they drifted apart and we have no idea where she is. My husband's version of the story was that the sister had only contacted the family looking for money. I don't know how true that is, but I do know that she only stay involved with the family for about a year before disappearing again. It's awkward for me, because I have a half-sister too, but I've grown up knowing her and can't imagine my life without her. Just goes to show that everyone can have a different experience with things in life.

    Source(s): Blessed to be a Mother thanks to adoption.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    While I was in my early teens my a-dad told me that he and an old girlfriend had a baby in the early 70's and that she was placed for adoption. My a-mom never knew. For many years I thought I had "made up" the story in my mind or dreamed of it. My dad never brought it up again.

    When I was 22 this daughter found my dad. I was shocked but at least I had the notion in my head. My brother didn't know anything about our dad having another child but he was happy to have another sibling, as was I. Today she is very much a part of our family and we are very blessed to have her in our lives.

    Source(s): The "chosen" one, picked out of a room full of babies.
  • 5 years ago

    You should definitely talk to your cousin FIRST if you absolutely must say something. Even if that was his picture up there, that may not have been him posting. People can steal pictures from Myspace, Facebook, LinkedIn, etc. and put them up on craigslist EASILY. It could be someone setting him up, pranking him, or it could really be him. Either way you should talk to him PRIVATELY first, and use a lot of finesse. It would be best if you talk to him over a beer or somewhere HE is comfortable so that its more of a casual situation. Don't demand to know if he is gay, or try to get a confession out of him by telling him that you have naughty pics of him. You never know, ya'll may end up growing closer because of the whole incident if you handle it correctly. Best.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    I am adopted and a secret to my mom's 2 biological children that are now young adults. I actually refer to myself to my mother as her dirty little secret. They are several years younger than me and have no idea that I even exist. My adoption was not quite right from the start and she and my father pretty much gave me back to the state. Until recently I have always been the one to maintain the relationship but finally realized that it was seriously damaging me on many levels. Never the less, she is my mother even after having met my biological mother. Meeting my biological mother in no way made me feel whole but it was nice to finally know where I came from.

    How does it make me feel, where do I start? I am angry beyond words, hurt, have feelings of being worthless and unwanted, not easily attached to anyone or anything (other than my children), resentment for her inability to live up to the commitment of having chosen a child. I feel that she robbed me of a childhood and ripped my kids off by not being a grand parent. Years of therapy have helped me to deal with it but in my entire lifetime I will never get over it.

    I am an accept people as you find them kind of person and I have finally accepted her for who she is and knew it was time for me to end the relationship. One day I will find the courage to tell her why I stopped answering her calls and emails.

    Source(s): Adoptee
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I think it depends on the people involved. To some people it doesn't matter how long or reason they can love anyone, yet others have a hard time loving themselves. The roads of life in some cases don't run smooth, but with the right care turn out to be wonderful. Your stories are an example of what can take place, the many ways that people withhold information for whatever reason, but in 99% of the cases love and forgiving overcomes anything. Sometimes it isn't easy for someone to admit to making a mistake, years pass until the time comes to let the truth be know, then people try to contact whomever they can to be whole

  • 1 decade ago

    Ooooooh. Weird. I just remembered that my amom had an older brother that suddenly showed up when she was a teenager. She was totally tripped out by it.

    I think that I would be, too. I have no blood siblings, which makes me kinda sad. I wish that I did. To think that I was a big sister would be a very happy thing to me, and I would totally want to meet them and be in contact with them.

    I think that it's similar to how I feel about my children and my natural parents...blood is so important, I can't help but see the similarities and FINALLY feel a little bit more normal that I wasn't created in a vacuum!

    Source(s): I am an adult adoptee.
  • 1 decade ago

    are you peeking in on my life? LOL! seriously, i just found my bio father and I AM THE SECRET! he was young, fresh out of vietnam and was into some bad things in his life. he and my birthmother decided it was in my best interests to put me up for adoption. they were right. they both ended up fine in the end, but the road they both traveled was no place for a child to be.

    when my birthmother and i found him he had told no one. he never thought in a million years i would come for him, he buried his pain and lived in silence. to the point he never married or had any other children. "i couldnt take care of you when you needed me, so i didnt have any other kids" his words, not mine. my birthmother waited 19 years to have another.

    anyway, 35 years later here i come, SURPRISE! ITS A GIRL! and his family was in the dark the whole time. i have met his mother and one sister. they are wonderful and i couldnt be happier. i still have plenty of other family i have to face, some not as open as others, but thats ok, i understand. if someone came out of nowhere and said they were my long lost niece i would be leery too. you have to protect your family. they dont want to see him get hurt. how can i get angry about them protecting him? it shows lots of character on their part. hopefully they will warm up to me over time.

  • 1 decade ago

    My son was was 23 when he found out he had a natural sister who was given up at birth. He was pretty mad at first that we had kept this information from him. If I had never looked for or found his birth sister, then he might never had known, because she was a secret i was prepared to take to my grave. But one day, I decided to look for her and I found her so I had to tell. That was back in 2001. They talk occasionally. He still loves me. She likes me. What more could I ask for?

    Source(s): reunited bmom
  • Sunny
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Well, as an adopted person in the closed system, I'm used to suprises, and would be excited by the prospect of a new relative.

    Source(s): Adult adoptee and family preservationist
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.