Which of these active players would make the Hall of Fame?

Ramirez - Yes

Mussina - no

Rivera - yes

Petitte - no

A-Rod - yes

Jeter - yes

Percival - no

Shilling - no

Thome - yes

Sheffield - no

Ordonez - no

Pudge Rodriquez - yes

Kenny Rogers - no

Guerrero - yes

Frank Thomas - yes

Ichiro - yes

Glavine - yes

Smoltz - yes

Chipper Jones - yes

Billy Wagner - no

Petro Martinez - yes

Alou - no

Griffey - yes

Jamie Moyer - no

Pujols - yes

Randy Johnson - yes

Helton - maybe

Garciaparra - no

Hoffman - yes

Maddux - yes

Carlos Delgado - no

(I changed some)

Ramirez - maybe

Mussina - maybe

Rivera - yes

Petitte - no

A-Rod - yes

Jeter - yes

Percival - no

Shilling - no

Thome - maybe

Sheffield - no

Ordonez - no

Pudge Rodriquez - maybe

Kenny Rogers - no

Guerrero - yes

Frank Thomas - maybe

Ichiro - yes

Glavine - yes

Smoltz - yes

Chipper Jones - no

Billy Wagner - maybe

Petro Martinez - yes

Alou - no

Griffey - yes

Jamie Moyer - no

Pujols - no

Randy Johnson - maybe

Helton - maybe

Garciaparra - no

Hoffman - yes

Maddux - yes

Carlos Delgado - no

"Yes" should be interpreted as "very likely" since there is no such thing as a Sure Thing for the Hall.

Ramirez - Manny yes, Aramis no, Hanley way too early.

Mussina - no.

Rivera - yes.

Petitte - no.

A-Rod - yes.

Jeter - yes.

Percival - no

Shilling - no.

Thome - yes.

Ordonez - no.

Pudge Rodriquez - yes, and the Hall will spell his name correctly on the plaque.

Kenny Rogers - no.

Guerrero - yes.

Frank Thomas - yes.

Ichiro - unfair, as he hasn't yet played the requisite 10 seasons minimum, but I'll project him to a yes anyway.

Glavine - yes.

Smoltz - yes.

Chipper Jones - yes.

Billy Wagner - no.

Petro Martinez - yes.

Alou - no.

Griffey - yes.

Jamie Moyer - no.

Pujols - see Ichiro note.

Randy Johnson - yes.

Helton - tough call. Great hitter, but played in Coors. Not done yet. I'm leaning No today, but he's got some seasons left and may yet tip the balance in his favor.

Garciaparra - no.

Hoffman - yes. Just look at the first three letters of his surname.

Maddux - yes.

Carlos Delgado - no, but see Helton note.

Sheffield - I moved Sheff to the bottom because to me he's a very precarious candidate. I loathe trying to evaluate him for the Hall. The numbers -- pretty good, perhaps enough on their own (and he's not done), but there's just something MISSING with Sheffield. He never seems to be the Big Guy, the one who'll hoist the team upon his shoulders and carry them. He's got a nonstop mouth that sets loose statements that don't win him any warm'n'fuzzy awards. There's allegations that he tanked some defensive plays in his youthful Milwaukee years. His name pops up in steroids smear pieces. He's just an incredibly diverse mixed bag, and I have no idea how the writers will approach his candidacy, because it's never JUST about the stats.

Ramirez - Yes

Mussina - no

Rivera - yes

Petitte - no

A-Rod - yes

Jeter - no

Percival - no

Shilling - no

Thome - no

Sheffield - no

Ordonez - no

Pudge Rodriquez - yes

Kenny Rogers - no

Guerrero - no

Frank Thomas - yes

Ichiro - yes (not limited to major league career)

Glavine - yes

Smoltz - yes

Chipper Jones - yes

Billy Wagner - no

Petro Martinez - yes

Alou - no

Griffey - yes

Jamie Moyer - no

Pujols - maybe

Randy Johnson - yes

Helton - no

Garciaparra - no

Hoffman - yes

Maddux - yes

Carlos Delgado - no

Ramirez - Yes

Mussina - no

Rivera - yes

Petitte - no

A-Rod - yes

Jeter - yes

Percival - no

Shilling - good chance

Thome - maybe

Sheffield - no

Ordonez - no

Pudge Rodriquez - yes

Kenny Rogers - no

Guerrero - yes

Frank Thomas - outside chance

Ichiro - maybe

Glavine - yes

Smoltz - yes

Chipper Jones - YES

Billy Wagner - no

Petro Martinez - yes

Alou - no

Griffey - yes

Jamie Moyer - no

Pujols - YES

Randy Johnson - yes

Helton - maybe

Garciaparra - no

Hoffman - yes

Maddux - yes

Carlos Delgado - no

Ramirez - Yes

Mussina - no

Rivera - yes

Petitte - no

A-Rod - yes

Jeter - yes

Percival - no

Shilling - yes

Thome - yes

Sheffield - no

Ordonez - no

Pudge Rodriquez - yes

Kenny Rogers - no

Guerrero - yes

Frank Thomas - yes

Ichiro - yes

Glavine - yes

Smoltz - yes

Chipper Jones - yes

Billy Wagner - no

Petro Martinez - yes

Alou - no

Griffey - yes

Jamie Moyer - no

Pujols - yes

Randy Johnson - yes

Helton - maybe

Garciaparra - no

Hoffman - yes

Maddux - yes

Carlos Delgado - no

Ramirez - Yes

Mussina - no

Rivera - yes

Petitte - no

A-Rod - yes

Jeter - yes

Percival - no

Shilling - no

Thome - yes

Sheffield - no

Ordonez - no

Pudge Rodriquez - yes

Kenny Rogers - no

Guerrero - yes

Frank Thomas - yes

Ichiro - yes

Glavine - yes

Smoltz - yes

Chipper Jones - yes

Billy Wagner - no

Petro Martinez - no

Alou - no

Griffey - yes

Jamie Moyer - no

Pujols - yes

Randy Johnson - yes

Helton - yes

Garciaparra - no

Hoffman - yes

Maddux - yes

Carlos Delgado - no

Basically almost every 500 Homer is in and every 300 Winner is in just 300 wins is rare now-a-days.

Ramirez - Yes (Especially when he gets 500)

Mussina - No

Rivera - Yes

Petitte - No

A-Rod - Yes

Jeter - Yes

Percival - no

Shilling - Yes

Thome - No

Sheffield - No

Ordonez - Maybe

Pudge Rodriquez - Heck Yes

Kenny Rogers - Maybe

Guerrero - Yes

Frank Thomas - Yes

Ichiro - Yes

Glavine - Yes

Smoltz - Yes

Chipper Jones - maybe (this may be deciding season)

Billy Wagner - no

Petro Martinez - maybe (hasn't been good lately)

Alou - no

Griffey - yes (almost 600 HRs automatic)

Jamie Moyer - No

Pujols - Yes

Randy Johnson - Yes

Helton - no

Garciaparra - no

Hoffman - yes (leader in saves has to get in)

Maddux - yes

Carlos Delgado - no

Mike Piazza will probably get in too.

Manny Ramirez - Yes

Mike Mussina - No

Mariano Rivera - Hells Yes

Andy Petitte - No

A-Rod - Yes

Derek Jeter - Yes

Troy Percival - No

Kurt Shilling - Yes

Jim Thome - Maybe (since he's a DH for his Career basically)

Gary Sheffield - No

Magglio Ordonez - No

Pudge Rodriquez - Yes

Kenny Rogers - No

Vlad Guerrero - Yes

Frank Thomas - Yes

Ichiro Suzuki- Hells Yes (200_ hit for 7 straight season with a .330+ BA)

Tom Glavine - Yes

John Smoltz - Hells Yes (He's the only guy I know who is a Dominate Closer and Pitcher)

Chipper Jones - Yes

Billy Wagner - No

Pedro Martinez - Yes

Moises Alou - No

Ken Griffey - Yes

Jamie Moyer - Hells No

Albert Pujols - No

Randy Johnson - Oh Yes

Todd Helton - Maybe

Nomar Garciaparra - No

Trevor Hoffman - No (Quantity does not equal Quality)

Maddux - Yes

Carlos Delgado - No

Ramirez - Yes

Mussina - No

Rivera - Maybe

Petitte - no

A-Rod - yes

Jeter - (still hasn't accomplished what a HOF career should be)

Percival - no

Shilling - no

Thome - maybe

Sheffield - maybe

Ordonez - no

Pudge Rodriquez - yes

Kenny Rogers - no

Guerrero - no (still hasn't accomplished what a HOF career should be)

Frank Thomas - Yes

Ichiro - NO!!! - 7 years in the major leagues.

Glavine - yes

Smoltz - yes

Chipper Jones - No

Billy Wagner - No

Petro Martinez - yes

Alou - no

Griffey - yes

Jamie Moyer - no

Pujols - no

Randy Johnson - yes

Helton - No

Garciaparra - no

Hoffman - maybe

Maddux - yes

Carlos Delgado - no

I gave all closers at MOST a maybe.

I will get the thumbs down for my no to Jeter, but really, if you look at his #'s and take away the name, he wouldn't make it if he retired now.

Bit of speed, 2300 hits, .300 average, average power. Whooop - di - do.

He will definitely need to get 3000 hits to get in and I would have said the EXACT same thing of Biggio when he was at 2300 hits.