Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Gun buffs! I need a history lesson!?
Tell me all about the relationship between the .410 shotgun shell, and the .45 long Colt.
Which came first? Why are they / Why did they become interchangeable?
7 Answers
- Doc HudsonLv 71 decade agoFavorite Answer
There is none.
The .410 shotgun is a smoothbore long gun with a bore diameter of .410". Only the strength of the action and barrels allow some folks to get away with shooting .45 LC cartridges in .410 shotguns. Eventually their luck will run out. Though a shotgun, the .410 is actually a caliber rather than a gauge.
There are some single-shot handguns and a few revolvers that are chambered in such a way that .410 shotgun shells can be fired in them. In general the revolvers are large, and clunky, and give people a false sense of security. In my opinion, the .410 is pretty well worthless for anything besides killing snakes at close range.
Check out The Box o' Truth's article on the Taurus Judge .45LC/.410 revolver: http://www.theboxotruth.com/docs/bot41_4.htm
Doc
Source(s): As for the history lesson, I guess I should offer the straight dope rather than the misinformation offered above. The .45 Colt, aka .45 Long Colt, was introduced along with a brand new cartridge revolver for the US Army in 1875. The revolver is variously known as the Colt Single-Action Army Revolver, the Colt Peacemaker, the Colt Model P, the Colt Frontier Six-Shooter, and finally the Colt New Frontier (and adjustable sighted version introduced in 1960). Shortly after the adoption of the Colt Single-Action Army, aka Colt SAA, Major John Schofield tinkered around with the design of the Smith & Wesson #3 Revolver (a break-top single-action revolver) to improve it as a cavalry arm. Schofield convinced Smith and Wesson to adopt his changes, and he convinced the Army to test the new revolver. The Army specified that the revolvers be chambered for the already adopted .45 caliber cartridge rather than the .44 caliber cartridges Smith & Wesson had been using. That caused a problem, because the #3's cylinder was too short to accommodate the .45 Colt's 1.285" long cartridge case. So S&W shortened the cartridge length to match the length of the .44 S&W Russian cartridge's 1.06" cartridge case. The Army bought several hundred of the Smith & Wesson Schofield revolvers for field testing. After a few disastrous instances of issuing the wrong cartridges to troops armed with the S&W revolvers, the Army started issuing only .45 S&W Schofield cartridges (the load was the same, just different cartridge lengths). The Army did not adopt the Smith & Wesson revolver and disposed of the pistols, but kept using the shorter cartridges. Then came the appearance of the Smith & Wesson .45's on the civilian market, and came the appellation .45 Long Colt to differentiate them from the .45 Short cartridges that would fit either the Colt or Smith & Wesson revolvers. The .45 Colt was the official US Army sidearm until 1892 when it was replaced by a double-action swing-out cylinder Colt revolver chambered in .38 Colt. The dismal performance of the underpowered .38 Colt lead not only to the troops clamoring for reissuance of a .45 caliber side arm, but also the development of the .38 S&W Special. Lots of old .45 SAA's were brought out of strategic reserve and reissued after 1901, and there were a number of DA .45 Colt New Service Model revolvers purchased as well. After 10 years of testing, and research, the Army adopted a cartridge that was ballistically identical to the old original .45 Colt blackpowder load, and adopted a semi-automatic pistol to shoot it. The cartridge was the .45 ACP, and the pistol the Colt Model of 1911. As for history of the .410 shotgun, I can't help you. It has never interested me enough to research it. Doc Nate, Did anyone ever tell you that you are a smart aleck? LOL Thanks for the kind words kbhiltsley and Randy - 1 decade ago
As stated in some of the other posts, the 45/410 guns, such as the Judge, are .452” bore guns that have a chamber sized so that it will accept a 45 Colt cartridge and a 410 shotgun shell. The cartridge case dimensions are similar enough to get away with it and I think that the chamber head end is slightly oversized (larger than a 410 chamber) in order to allow it to accept the 45 round. The head of a 410 case is about .469” and the head of a 45 Colt is about .480” in diameter. This chamber is unique to these guns, since it has a length based on the 410 and a head diameter based on the 45 Colt. To get a 45 Colt round to go into a standard 410 chamber would be very difficult unless a lot of force was used. That should stop anyone from attempting to actually fire a 45 Colt in a 410, and it definitely does not imply that a 45 Colt is interchangeable with the 410 shotgun shell. That is a misnomer that naturally came about when guns were introduced with the 45/410 chamber. A 45 Colt bullet has a nominal diameter of .452” (bullets are available from .451 to .454) and is designed to be fired in a barrel of similar diameter. A 410 shotgun barrel has a .410” bore diameter. The .410” shot column will fire suitably in a bore of .452” (since it is of smaller diameter), but a solid bullet of .452” diameter will not fit a .410” diameter barrel and would cause a serious overpressure. There is a website that explains the history of the 410 shotgun shell which is very informative at <http://cartridgecollectors.org/410/collecting410.h... Some of the older single shot break open shotguns are marked 44/410 on the barrel. I have one of these guns which passed down through my family from the late 1800s. It was the first gun my dad hunted with when he was a boy and also the first gun that I hunted with. I even succeeded in downing a quail on the wing with it when I was about 12 years old. The 44/410 marking was unexplained until I ran across the 410 collector’s site. The marking is not meant to imply that a 44 caliber bullet (which is .430” dia) could be fired in a 410 shotgun (this is another misnomer). A 44-40 cartridge will fit nicely in the chamber. However, a 44 shot shell was available, probably 100 to 130 years ago, that was called the 44XL, which could be fired in a 410 shotgun, and some of the 410s were thusly marked. The 44XL had a wooden shot capsule similar to plastic shot caps available today. One other note of caution is that the 454 Casull cartridge will fit the chamber of some of the 45/410 guns. That is a dangerous combination. The pressure created by a 454 load will blow these guns apart. http://cartridgecollectors.org/410/collecting410.h...
- kbhiltsleyLv 61 decade ago
Doc Hudson's insight into the .45LC is a good history lesson.
But, the amount of misinformation offered by others above is both amazing and dangerous!! These rounds are definitely NOT interchangeable, except in a few very specialized firearms (such as Taurus' Judge) designed specifically for that purpose.
While the case diameter may be similar the maximum overall length of a .45 Long Colt cartridge is 1.60". The shortest .410 shotshell currently made is 2.5". Now, how do our experts propose squeezing that shotshell into a standard revolver chamber????
- randyLv 71 decade ago
I started scrolling down thru the answers and was really getting set to straighten out some dangerous beliefs when I got to Docs answer. he stated it just about perfectly and I am glad he got to give all the details. Just mind what he said, and what was repeated by the guy after him, they are not interchangeable in most firearms. Only a few specialized firearms with chambers designed longer and stronger can accept both, trying to fire a .45lc in a .410 shotgun can cause it to explode with series injury or death resulting.
good job Doc.
Source(s): Retired Police Officer NRA certified police firearms instructor Trained at GLOCK, COLT and S&W armorers schools Ran a gun shop for many years Fired both rifle and handgun competitions And have been an avid hunter since age 9 with Archery, Black Powder, Shotgun, Handgun and Modern Rifle SI VIS PACEM PARA BELLUM (If you want peace, prepare for war) - How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- 1 decade ago
.45 Long colt was developed first as a higher velocity version of the standard 45. it was released in late 1872 and replaced the heavier .50 cal single shot.
It spent al long time as a premier pistol hunting cartridege an was the basis for the .454 casull
the .410 bore si the smallest shotgun cartridge and is a versitile survival round designed for close range situations. Though it is based off the .45 cartridge in dimensions the two were not designed to be interchangeable. It was discovered after some curious gun smiths looked at the measurements that the two rounds are of almost identical length and diameter it was at that time the 45-410 combo came to be.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
The 45 was invented during the late 1800's. At the time, the 45 Schofield was being used. The 45 Colt was invented to compete. Someone started calling the Colt the "Long" colt to keep the two seperate (from getting mixed up), but "Long" is not nor was ever intended to be used. It is simply, the 45 Colt.
When we say long we are suggesting there is a short, and there has only ever been the 45 Colt.
The 410 came in quite a bit later to allow all the people shooting a Colt the chance to use their guns to shoot birds and such.
I don't know when the 410 came into being, but know some of it's intentions (among other things) was to give the 45 Colt owner other options.
Source(s): Ammo man - Colter BLv 51 decade ago
I don't know the history..... but they are interchanged because they will both fit in the same sized barrel. You get two guns for the price of one, in essence.