Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Stigmata against philosophy?
I recently conducted a survey to get peoples view on philosophy. Overwhelmingly, the response was bad. People had little or no exposure to the subject and often felt that it was "stupid." They were so put off by it, that they said they would categorically refuse to investigate it further. So my question is, why? What is seen as so repugnant? Is there something in the subject itself or do you think it is due to other factors?
In response to Vbasic: Isn't the use of philosophy (metaphysics, logic, epistemology) implicit in other scientific disciplines?
Todd, thanks for the correction. I'm ill right now and a littled muddied.
9 Answers
- ToddLv 51 decade agoFavorite Answer
Many people have an anti-intellectual bias. The way that philosophy will go on and on picking a topic to death, looking at in from every angle, with a lot of "on the other hand"s, is tiresome to some people. They look at that the way they would a lawyer cross-examining them -- as unpleasant.
They also don't see an immediate reward. And there may not be one. If I am pursuing philosophy for pleasure or the "greater good," you could just see your doing that as not your cup of tea, like you could be apolitical or not like sports. Not all people are capable of intellectual pursuits.
But ultimately, if you wonder about the larger world around you, you'll be using philosophy sooner or later to think through a big question.
(I believe you mean "stigma," rather than "stigmata.")
- 1 decade ago
I would say that the reason behind the utter disinterest in the "diligent inquiry" behind philosophy is two-fold:
1. Physical inability. The mental faculties of the person may have lesser capabilities of understanding the vast complexities behind the main tenets of the great philosophical understandings of life, which extends to metaphysics. Unfortunately and respectfully, there are those who do have "simple minds" even if their mentality has not been retarded (appropriate usage).
2. Indolence and temporal demands. Specifically, one may find great disinterest in the amount of time needed to pursue the "diligent inquiry" for the sake of less tasking opportunities. We live in a vain society, wherein the greatest and most profound undertaking is to sate their hedonistic appetites through gossip, sitcoms, video games, parties, drugs, alcohol, and the like. Next, though, is not as impressively unsettling, but rather admirable, which is that the individual may not have the ability to pursue "diligent inquiry" for demands on their life through monetary and or familial means. It seems, though, that even among many who study philosophy still suffer at these latter issues, slightly, which brings me to a thought that many of the greatest minds were recluses.
Edit:
Philosophy and science were once bedfellows in learned communities, however, it seems in most recent times that the link between the two has been severed. While both use many of the same methods and arriving at particular answers - save, perhaps, metaphysics, which is reserved for the philosopher and virtually ignored by the scientist - they can often arrive at different conclusions: the end of philosophy or "diligent inquiry" being postulated as the divine things, whereas the end of science would seem to stop at nature itself, being that it is the study of nature.
Peace and love,
Phillip
- boyterLv 44 years ago
ok, nicely there is not something 'incorrect' with nudity in itself.there's a time and a place however(e.g.Janet Jackson), and in all societies they might variety.interior the western international we are frequently lined up. once you strip off in an environment like a bar or club,the foremost purpose is to make money for your self and the owners etc.merely comparable to there is not something incorrect with intercourse, purely while it gets bought is the place lower back, you start up going on the slippery slope. the different purpose this is of no problem to you is the tittilation and fantasisation which happens(specifically with men). Its result could be as little from a pair arguing over whether that's ok of their relationship for the guy to computer screen strippers, to a girl being raped through consistent degrading or erosion of the womans sexuality till they are actually not something extra suitable than sexual products or bits of meat. i'm constructive you have a great character and a physique this is fantastically wonderful to all adult men, yet even with the reality which you have been truthful on your reasons for doing this and made your money,did every person else get harm interior the approach? How do you think of your dad and mom felt approximately raising you up which you would be able to sell your physique in this way? .
- 1 decade ago
Most people are only concerned with TV shows, video games, celebrities, Ipods, getting wasted on the weekend etc. Philosophy requires intelligence and the ability to think deeply about difficult subjects and material. Most people have little desire to engage in critical thinking, outside of what is perhaps required for their profession/job, and philosophy bores many people because they simply don't have the capacity to understand it, or even if they do, they would rather engage in mindless activities. Governments, corporations, Wall street-- love stupid, thoughtless people because these people act like sheep throughout their entire lives, blindly buying what's advertised in front of them, keeping up with the Joneses mentality. They are very easily manipulated and controlled.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
I think that the general consensus about Philosophy is that it is idle daydreaming.
Though general consensus is usually incorrect, it is not difficult to understand this attitude since, for example, so many people who post here seem to think of themselves as Philosophers and enter rambling diatribes which are difficult to take seriously.
We all have our own Philosophy of life based on life experience and what we've read and heard and we express our own preconceptions constantly.
Few of us, however, call ourselves Philosophers.
I know a person who can talk Philosophy for hours and make my head hurt. She's brilliant, and, I'm sure, would never claim to be a Philosopher.
- 1 decade ago
When I was taking my first philosophy class I came across the same phenomenon as you; many of my friends, who I always thought were free thinkers, absolutely shunned philosophy for no apparent reason. I was perplexed to say the least. Upon further goading, I was able to find out that the majority of them were of the firm belief that philosophy disproved religion, as such; they were inclined to shy away from it.
- 1 decade ago
I think some cannot think too deep some can and are scared by the depth of the human mind and others because there is no money in philosophy
- vbasicLv 51 decade ago
Maybe because people want to live their lives and not reflect on ultimate causes. The success of science, technology and practical work and leisure in our lives, probably cause people to think there is no reason to study philosophy.
- smallLv 71 decade ago
Perhaps a lot of people see it as intellectual waste of time without any practical use in real life!!