Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
what would you say if your child wanted to change his sex?
would you be okay to let them change from a girl to a boy? or a boy to a girl?
Why?
my child /children do not want to do this. I actually watched a show on special victims unit the other night on this.
I wouldn't care personally, if they felt trapped in a body that wasn't how they felt, then I would want them to be happy.
It would be hard to digest in the beginning, but I would have to accept it.
Hey I have not given any one a thumbs down.
SWEETGRa- okay now, I have given a thumbs down. I am not a homowhatever, and if I play with toys with my husband is no of your business lol.
let me repeat this is not about my kids as it is a about a law and order special victims unit show we watched on tuesday night.
As many of you have already seen I have asked three very different questions and from most have gotten three very different answers,
there will be one more question ....
25 Answers
- sharonlynnvnLv 61 decade agoFavorite Answer
I am often appalled at the mindless ,arrogant, and hateful ignorance I see here.
Shame on you who should love and care for your child!
First off this is about gender identity not sexual orientation. This manifests itself predominantly at extreme early stages as one begin to see our sad binary concept world. I knew at 3 that I was a girl and acted that way all of my life in one form or another. The one and only reason to reject this or have a difficult time with it is your own conditioning and not the child's. This is extremely painful to live with which is why nearly 40% of us do not survive. It is you who hate mindlessly quoting anything you can to hide behind. This includes religious intolerance, which is often escalated to violence. To put a child through puberty which is wrong for them is pure torture! Such hate is a sad commentary. I even know of a neo-nazi who is tolerant of us so what does that say about the rest here?
Sharon
Also it takes substantial therapy to progress through many hoops to even get to HRT!
- MutchkinLv 61 decade ago
I would be happy with what my child is happy with. It will take a bit to get used to (calling him a her or a her to a him) but that comes with time of course. But I would not shun them or disown them like many parents often do.
Before they would get any medical altering, I would strongly advise that they receive counseling (which often is required) to make sure that is what they want and to sort out any issues they can be facing.
I would require my child to wait til they are an adult to any altering or medications, but if they wanted to experiment with cross dressing, I would support, but strongly put them in counseling so they can develop the skills of how to handle negative remarks from society. The world is cruel and not understanding of ones desires. That is a strong thing they would need to be prepared for.
Source(s): Proud wife of an US Marine - 1 decade ago
You should sit down and have a good talk with your child, find out why he/she wants something as drastic as a sex change. As been mentioned before nothing wrong with being homosexual, but it sounds like your child is confused and is making a decision based on a whim.
Personally I don't think it's a good idea for a child to have a sex change, because they might regret it when they grow older and becomes more mature and realizes that wasn't what they really wanted.
- gabrilaLv 45 years ago
My toddlers can do what they sense they must do to be satisfied and that i visit assist them, in spite of if its not person-friendly for me to understand. even if, they are going to ought to pay for the operations themselves while they turn 18. Im not produced from money, and the operations are extremely costly. On acceptable of that, they have extra time to compliment no be counted if this is something they actually think of is well worth doing. in the event that they sense that way at 18 then they could make that govt call and have it achieved. Im basically not likely to sign my call to an eternal determination of that nature. Its completely changing somebody i've got widely used and enjoyed all their lifestyles. i could not carry myself to be an element of reducing them up and rearranging them. i visit settle for it and love them basically the comparable in the event that they bypass with the aid of with it, yet I wont help them do it. with a bit of luck they might understand.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- 1 decade ago
We had custody of two of my cousin's children last year. Matthew is 6 and insists on wearing girls clothes and being called Madeline. We were really worried at first but in no time, he was just pretty little Maddy. He knows that he has to wear his boys clothes when he goes out.
If one of my own children decides they want to change sex, they can wait until they're 30.
- AmberPLv 71 decade ago
I think in most cases like this, you notice that they feel uncomfortable with their gender around the age of puberty.. maybe even younger, maybe even older..
Once again i'd be a bit shocked at first, I'd possibly ask them why they felt that way..but if they feel that they wanted to change their sex then that is ultimately their choice. I'd be supportive of them no matter what their decision was..as they are my child!
- amber mLv 51 decade ago
I would do my best to accept it and be okay with it. I would not allow the surgery as a child but once they are adults and able to make their own decision I would be ok with it.
- MeLv 51 decade ago
Yes, I would be okay with it. My only rules about it would be they have to pay for it themselves (the surgeries) and be over 18. My reason for number 1 is if I can't afford to pay for my child's college, I won't pay for unneeded plastic surgery. Rule number 2 is that anything this life changing shouldn't be taken lightly and there should be a lot of hard thinking on it.
The reason I'd be okay with it is because you have one life, why would any parent want their child uncomfortable in their own skin? Life isn't worth living if you're constantly sad about the person you are, so if you can change it to make yourself happy, why not?
- Anonymous1 decade ago
The kid is expressing his/her own personality if they want to get a sex change... It may not be natural in any way but if that's what they really wanna do then who are you to stop them? I wouldn't care if I had kids that wanted to get a sex change... I would probably say "Good for you."
- 1 decade ago
whoa big question.from what i have seen many children nowadays want to do that because they are either heart broken or because of their environment.i have a friend who is a guy and wants to be a girl because of his parents.so i would advice to ask the kid what exactly is in his mind.