Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
How is Jesus, Moses, known by Muhammed, etc. pt. 3?
To convert the people of Makkah as his followers, he took the offensive against them. He adopted means which went against the hallowed traditions of the ancient Arabs and repeatedly gave offence to his followers—for instance when he caused a Makkan caravan to be attacked during a sacred month. He claimed “divine revelations” told him to do it. This tendency became more and more conspicuous in Muhammad, namely, to make supernatural manifestations justify humanly reprehensible actions, such as the move against a Jewish tribe in Madinah on the ground of a “revelation” permitting the breach of a treaty between him and the Jews if one of them was suspect.
Muhammad’s attitude towards Christians and the Mosaic changed considerably with the growth of his “prophetic consciousness.” Initially he had believed that both denominations would forthwith recognize him as standing in the line of their heritage and therefore concur with his preaching. When nothing of this sort came to pass, and when the Jews more and more drew his attention to contradictions in his revelations on Old Testament themes, he turned against them with mounting repugnance and seized upon what was, in the circumstances, the appropriate expedient – that of describing their traditions as intentionally falsified and presenting himself as the restorer of the religion of Abraham, founder of the Kabah and its cult. In so doing, he of course renounced the claim to be the first Prophet of his nation. This assertion was not open to disproof, though it was not well grounded because neither he nor his followers could read or understand the scriptures in their garb of foreign tongues. Even had they been able to do so, it would have been an easy thing to suggest that these writings had been deliberately altered by the ancestors of their then living devotees and that references in them to Muhammad had been excised. Common people, who know nothing of textual criticism or the comparative history of religions, are quite powerless against such a reproach, and even today a convinced Muslim will, when the Scriptures and the Qur’an are compared, hold fast to this view and so put every objection out of court (without proof). For Muhammad it meant that his alleged oversights were not errors, but rectifications by which the “falsifications” of his adversaries were unmasked. (conclusion of 3 pts. of condensed section.)
This has been a condensed version of Spuler, The Age of the Caliphs, History of the Muslim World, pp. 5-8. The full book can be found on many bookselling sources.
You correctly thought this was fiction because the references were not supplied in Pt. 3. They were listed in Pt. 1 and Pt. 2. The listing is extended enabling further comments.
Of the hundreds of authors in the bibliography, only a few can be shown here.
The Age of the Caliphs, History of the Muslim World, (624-1479), Spuler,
Bertold, 1969; Weiner, Pub. Princeton. Bibliography contains over 300 studies
(books) from 624 A.D. to the end of the Mongols in Spain, 1609)
The Mongol Period, History of the Muslim World, (1162, Jingiz to the last of
the Tartars in Russia, 1944) Spuler, Bertold, 1969 pub. Weiner, Princeton.
250 titles published.
The Last Great Muslim Empires, Kissling, Hans, J., Weiner, Weiner, Pub.
Princeton, Bibliography of over 300 scholarly titles published.
Encyclopedia of Islam, 1936, 4 vols. Library of Congress.
3 Answers
- jb125Lv 51 decade agoFavorite Answer
You are entitled to your misguided rants on prophet Muhammad and the Holy Quran, but it does not change anything in as far as the truth goes. Didn't you know that the stories of the 25 main prophets (messengers) of Allah (God) are captured in the Holy Quran?
Allah revealed to Muhammad the stories about Adam, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Joseph, Moses, Solomon, David, and others. Allah also revealed the three books revealed earlier to David (the Zaboor or the Book of Psalms), Moses (the Taurat or Torah) and Jesus (the Injeel or New Testament).
Allah also revealed that the Holy Quran (as revealed to Muhammad) supersedes the other three earlier books sent to David, Moses and Jesus. Those books you mentioned are written explicitly by men to smear the truth as contained in the Holy Quran; so were the Old Testament, and the New Testament for that matter.Therefore I just cannot buy your line of arguments.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
If I am not mistaken Muhammad lived about the same time as Jesus both being descendants of two different Jewish tribes, David and Abraham. Muhammad knew of Jesus and Moses through interacting With other Jewish scholars, possibly reading the bible as it was written at the time. A historical document, sacred to the Jewish Population then and now.
Source(s): Hearing a dscourse on the subject many years ago.