Am I a bad person for abandoning her?

No your not a bad person you tried unlike some people that would not of bothered and he just dumped the dog with you

well done for trying and you have done the right thing and don't feel bad!

Aphrodite until you are those shoes dont judge she tried and that should be all that matters!

No I don't think that you are a bad person for giving the dog to aspca. Its better for the dog to be given to the aspca then your local animal shelter, who will probably end up euthanizing the dog after sometime. If you can't properly take care of the dog or train the dog yourself, then its better for the aspca to take care of the dog who can find an owner who will train the dog properly and give the dog the love and care it deserves. So no, I wouldn't say that you are wrong or bad in doing so. Most people would probably just leave the dog outside and not take care of it or just dump it somewhere and leave. You did the right thing.

You're not a bad person, you're just a bad dog owner (both you and your husband). A lot of people are. Inexperienced dog owners should never get dogs such as Akitas. They needs lots of training, exercise, and should not be "coddled", otherwise they will think they are dominant over you (peeing on the laundry, not accepting of the people you have over).

You and your ex-husband should have had her professionally trained when you got her. There was still hope for her, but it's too late now. Is the shelter you dropped her off a gassing shelter?

Well you and your husband took her in as a responsibility together, and if he is a marine you would know he would be away for much of the year. Meaning you would be the one training her. Looks like no one bothered to train her at all, judging by the way she was acting, and you never called in a professional trainer to work with her. If she doesn't get put down in the SPCA (unlikely, due to her behavior) then she might get a home where her new owner can deal with her problems.

No i don't think so.

You gave her to a rescue center where they can re-home her, if you had abandoned her on the streets or hurt her that would make you a bad person but you did the right thing.

If you couldn't afford her or control her and you didn't really want her it's much better for both you and the dog for her to go to a new home.

Don't feel guilty.

Okay. It is bad to give her up, but you said you lost your job, and no money, well the best thing to do is put her in a shelter so someone else could take her home, feed her. So I think you did the right thing.

well I would say he should have found someone to take care of his dog other than just dumping her on you but you kept her so I think it was up to you to take care of her but as you said you could not afford her bills so I think you did the right thing in trying to find her a new home that could afford her.

for the reason that neither human beings lived with the McCains throughout the time of that quantity of time neither human beings is able to decide. it particularly is definitely a time to persist with the best e book and determine not! as far through fact the guy who called you boastful. He replaced into completely suited!

You did your best with the resources you had and in the circumstances you found yourself in......no one can ask any more. Hopefully she will have found a new home, with someone who can give her the training and care she needs

I take it you're not very educated on dogs. Or educated at all judging by your English.

This dog was a puppy that you clearly had no time to train properly or take it out for exercise. That's the only reason why that dog was misbehaving - you never gave it any structure.

I can't stand when people just give up on puppies, but your dog is probably better with a new owner who can actually spend time with it.