Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
I thought this was absolutely ludacris!!! What do you think?
Just curious as to wether anyone agrees with this BS County legislation?
LAWSUIT FILED TO CHALLENGE BROWARD’S UNFAIR DOG ORDINANCE:
A lawsuit was filed Friday, September 5, 2008, to challenge Broward County’s new amendment to their “Dangerous Dog” ordinance. The suit was filed in Broward County Circuit Court on behalf of Julie Roberts, whose four Siberian Huskies were seized by Broward’s Animal Control on August 25 after an altercation with a neighbor’s dog allegedly caused the neighbor’s dog’s death. While the Siberian Huskies were supposed to be executed today, Roberts’ attorney, Jason M. Wandner, was able to make some progress in delaying the killing of these loved pets. Wandner has secured the Huskies’ relocation from “Death Row” at a Broward County animal shelter in Fort Lauderdale to an independent facility, more amenable to their welfare. The dogs will remain at this independent facility until the case is resolved and until Wandner and Roberts can pursue all available legal challenges to the proceedings.
Roberts’ Huskies are being charged under Broward County’s new law which classifies any dog as dangerous if it kills another dog off of the owner’s property, irrespective of whether the offending dog has had any previous bite history or history of aggression. Current Florida law gives all dogs a second chance, but not according to Broward County’s new amendment which stipulates that the first offense is no defense.
The lawsuit claims that the Broward County law is invalid because it conflicts with state law. The lawsuit states that under Florida law, “a dog that has not been previously designated as dangerous may not be destroyed unless it attacks and causes severe injury or death to a human.” None of the four Huskies in this case have ever been previously designated as dangerous, and therefore cannot be automatically destroyed for causing the death of another dog under Florida law. The lawsuit seeks to have the Broward County ordinance, which is subordinate to Florida law, declared invalid and the Huskies returned to their owner.
The lawsuit additionally explains how Roberts’ Huskies accidentally got out of her home and ran down the street. The Huskies came across a much smaller dog, and at some point during the encounter, the smaller dog died. It is unknown what actually caused the dog’s death, and there is no indication that a necropsy of the dog has been performed.
“Our hearts go out to Ms. Roberts’ neighbor. She has lost not only a loving pet, but a part of her family. While we understand the grief associated with this misfortune, her loss does not justify the senseless slaughter of four Huskies that are just as loved, and who accidentally got away from their owner,” said Wandner. “This was a tragic accident, and the law is just plain unfair. This could have happened to any pet owner and Broward County will be sending a terrible message to the community if an entire family of good dogs is killed because of an accident,” Wandner continued.
A total of five Huskies share the home with Ms. Roberts, Damien, the father (age five); Ivy, the mother (age three) and the puppies Champion, Dimberland and Chloe (all two years of age). Damien was not involved in the incident and is home alone waiting for the return of the rest of his family.
Attorney Jan Michael Morris, representing the South Florida Siberian Husky Rescue, Inc., a local organization devoted to finding homes for abused, neglected and abandoned purebred Siberian Huskies, says that what Broward County is doing should scare any pet owner living within the county.
“With the stroke of a pen, Broward County can now sentence any dog within the county to death. Even humans who commit murders and intentionally kill get a second chance,” said Morris. “This is not a case where a group of vicious dogs were routinely roaming the streets like a wild pack of animals. They were spayed, neutered, registered and kept indoors at all times,” said Morris. “According to an elusive amendment, the first offense is no defense and now dogs can be euthanized, no matter how careful, attentive and responsible pet owners may be. We need pet owners to be aware that this law exists and that unless something is done, it will have an overwhelmingly negative impact on the lives of many pet owners who may end up in the same unfortunate situation as Ms. Roberts,” pleaded Morris.
While the fight is far from over, Wandner has been able to temporarily calm Roberts’ worst fear of losing four out of her five pets. “Getting the county to approve our motion to relocate the dogs was a great step forward in our efforts to challenge the legality of the ordinance, and to ultimately save all four of the Huskies’ lives,” Wandner said.
If you would like to help in Roberts’ fight, log onto www.savethehuskies.com to learn more about her pet family and to sign the “Save the Huskies” petition.
Jen_ Dogs are ASNIMALS. Predatory animals ALL have prey drives-Even Goldeb Retreivers. If it was my dog that was killed, I would be heartbroke, BUT I would NEVER call for the slaughter of 4 other dogs that are just doing what is instinctual. That would be completely callous.
Hmmm... The dogs didn't attack a human, they killed a dog. I do think that mandatory training and even some sort of restrictions about supervision may be called for, but 4 lives sjhould NOT be taken. If it was a Pitbull would you say the same thing????
5 Answers
- JenVTLv 71 decade agoFavorite Answer
They KILLED someone else's pet. Honestly, if the shoe was on the other foot, how would you feel? I agree that they should be kept someplace safe until the legal proceedings are finished, but there should be some ramifications for what happened. What is to stop it from happening again? Dog owners should be held responsible and a dog that leaves it's property and KILLS another dog is dangerous. Period.
ADD: Craig- none of the links worked for me. regardless of the circumstances, I stand by my reply. I own a breed that is on BSL lists world wide. Owners with breeds like that have to take extra precautions to make sure that their dogs are above reproach so that BSL doesn't continue to spread. Dogs like this will give huskies a bad name for sure, even if it is an instinctual impulse.
- 1 decade ago
Even humans who commit murders and intentionally kill get a second chance,” said Morris.
-------------------------
Not quite, they serve jail time first. Is she willing to pay to send her dogs to a trainer (the equivalent of doggie jail) so that they may be corrected like prisoners /should/ be in jail? Finding a reputable trainer to teach her dogs obedience and control would convince me to let her have her dogs back if she could prove she could control them from now on. Besides, why do you need 5 active dogs cooped up in one house and never letting them out? I'd try to get out too.
But, no. These dogs should not be put down.
- MartineLv 45 years ago
Sellout Nigguh. Went from Sothern Hospitality and I Got Hoes to Justin Beiber and My Chick BAD SMFH.
- stacy gLv 41 decade ago
I agree this is wrong. They always want to put animals down, what about Humans that murder they get slapped on the wrist and live Go Figure
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Craig MLv 61 decade ago
I agree that it is wrong to kill the dogs. You need to know all the circumstances to understand this.
Source(s): http://gomestic.com/pets/dogs-and-thunde%E2%80%A6 http://gomestic.com/pets/things-dogs-do/ http://www.picable.com/Kole-and-Katie-Do%E2%80%A6 http://www.picable.com/MY-Babies-KOLIE-D%E2%80%A6 http://www.picable.com/Nature/Dogs/Throw%E2%80%A6