Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Isn't there more than proofs?

I love my rationality, I'm good at it and it's taken good care of me. But I was just listening to some of my favorite music (headphones, lots of volume) and it blows me away. I get tears in my eyes some parts. Music is so powerful, I can't believe it's just chemicals in my brain. Don't you guys feel that too sometimes? There are emotions too powerful to be just our programming via DNA and evolution, I think. Maybe you don't have those feelings and maybe that's the difference between people who think God is possible and those who don't. So I'm asking you nonbelievers, is that what it is? Nothing in your life feels like more than chemicals and electricity and science? No mystery, no magic, it's all the atomic table and accidents?

Update:

edit - Wow Skywalker, looks like you and I are the only ones who've noticed Dr. Science doesn't have all the answers. I'm surprised and disappointed.

8 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Waiting for a silly scientific explanation

  • 1 decade ago

    May I politely offer that reason calls this to attention, "...I can't believe it's just chemicals in my brain." is an argument from ignorance. What you or I can not believe is not a sound base for our view of reality. That we have seen the brain is the organ from which thought comes, that thought has never been demonstrated to have another source, and that the functions of the brain appear to be strictly chemical in nature, leads me to think that it is a matter of chemicals in you brain.

    Life is full of mystery, more so, in fact, if I do not allow magic as an easy explanation for the unknown.

  • ?
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    It's not magic. It is chemicals in your brain. In fact there's a scientific formula to make music that will affect the masses in this way. Not just that, but there's an ancient formula that still holds true today, look up "The golden mean", it was a way of composing music to make sure people would like it. There's a whole range of sounds, ranging from binurial beats, to theta waves, that can actually physically change the way your brain works (while your listening to it anyway).

    Source(s): Music Degree
  • 1 decade ago

    What I find ironic about this whole discussion is that many of them will turn around and tell you that their lack of belief in God is due to logical reasons, usually mentioning something along the lines that there isn't any evidence for such a being. However, if their emotions are merely just chemical reactions in their brains, then why isn't the same true for their lack of belief in God? If what they believe is true, it should be irrelevant whether God exists or not, they should believe or disbelieve in His existence solely due to the balance of chemicals in their brains rather than whether such a belief is logical or illogical.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    I don't think it's just chemicals. I think it's JUST CHEMICALS! That neurotransmitters, the configuration of axons, neurons, dendrites and synapses, and a little electricity, reproduced BILLIONS of times (do you know how BIG a billion is? Count out loud, 24/7, and it will take you over thirty years to count to one measly billion) can produce such sublime emotions is INCREDIBLE! It's awe inspiring. It's why Einstein thought that if there were any sort of God, it was expressed in the natural wonders of the universe, not the supernatural.

    http://pantheism.net/

  • Rachel
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    Please take the time to watch "The extended mind: Recent experimental evidence" on you tube. Its a fascinating lecture that goes for over an hour, but well worth a listen. Our minds do indeed have a little bit of magic, and a little bit of mystery, which science is just starting to aknowledge & uncover. It has nothing to do with 'god'.

  • 1 decade ago

    The mind isn't a computer, it doesn't react solely based on stimuli, it also reacts based on your thought processes.

    Some soldiers don't flinch when they kill another man. They are desensitised.

    You cry because you are sensitive to the music (I hardly know anyone who crys over music, what song was it anyway?).

    Your reaction is because of your thought processes, stimuli aren't defined as "sad" or "happy" it's your thoughts that make the stimuli (in this case the music) upsetting.

    tl;dr Your mind's interpretation of things makes you sad, not your genetics.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    not really i feel normal .i have so many things to worry in life right now (im gonna start college,move out) and i never though bout stupid crap like this but now that u mentioned it

    how does it feel to belive in god.oh ! i kno kinda like belivin in santa claus ahh! silly goose!

    well i dnt belive in santa or god

    but im very open minded

    and i love life! i clean i recycle cos i dnt wnna cause harm to earth

    and i preferto belive in the truth than to lie to myself and belive in santa and god

    reality is never easy or as cool as magic and all that mumble jumble.. but is reality!

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.