Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

TRANSGENDER: is s/he genuine?

heh, long story, but i would sincerely appreciate your opinion on this, yes?

i have a friend. born female, who for most of her early teenage life was comfortable identifying as such. recently, she has become interested in 'Yaoi' or homo-erotic fantasies between men, and as far as i can remember she has always been interested in cosplay, or other roleplaying games. a few months ago, she decided she was bi-sexual and found a girlfriend who also enjoyed yaoi and roleplay. but, in the last two weeks, my female friend has began requesting we refer to her as 'him'. s/he got his/her haircut short, has taken to binding his/her breasts, and wears male clothing. naturally, as his/her friend, i try my hardest to offer support, but i cant help but feel a little... uncomfortable with this sudden inexplicable change. emotionally, they act very much the same as always. that is, he/she retains many of the emotional tendencies of a female, and so i often make the mistake of mis-adressing, refering by defult and entirely by accident to said person as 'she'. at first i worried about it, but then i began to realize hey, s/he doesn't even seem to notice. on top of that, i have noted that on numerous occasions s/he has accidentally referred to him/herself as female without being aware of it, and i must admit i interpreted this as a signal that something was not quite right with this situation.

i have a loose theory, that is that s/he has taken on this new male identity as a roleplay in much the same way s/he would assume a cosplay character, in order to share the homo-erotic fantasies with his/her partner. after all, the likely hood of finding a MALE partner willing to accept that their girlfriend enjoys yaoi is low. of course, this theory may be entirely wrong, s/he may be being quite genuine about the whole thing, i just... it sounds horrible but i truely feel that there is something fishy about the whole thing.

im not uncomfortable with him/her being transgender in the least, but i am uncomfortable with the thought that perhaps it is all an act, and that by acting in this manner s/he is being disrespectful and immature.

what do you guys think? am i reading to far into this? do you believe s/he is genuine and im just being a jerk?

maybe i am just being a jerk. :/

3 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    You're not being a jerk. You're being a concerned friend.

    In addition to what clones said, I'd just say that I transitioned in January. Since then, I have referred to myself as male twice. Habits developed over the course of half a century are hard to break. I hear it every time someone uses my old name or says "he", but I don't correct people every time. First off, it's not always possible without major interruptions. Secondly, you have to give people a break - I mean, if I make that mistake, how can I yell at someone else for doing it? Third, I don't want a reputation as a b___h. So, perhaps your friend is simply cutting you some slack.

    I agree with Clones. Let him identify as he will, and do your best to support him. If he's really trans, eventually he'll find his way to a counselor and start getting things straightened out. If not, this too shall pass.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    im sorry to say that if you feel that you may be just being a jerk, then maybe that is what is true. I dont see why it should be open to discussion whether they are "genuine", its their life and their choice

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Instinct ALWAYS wins out. Don't ignore your own gut. Your friend is seriously messing with evil things...and needs help. I would distance myself so as not to get sucked into it.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.