Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

FuzzyMuffin asked in PetsDogs · 8 years ago

Puppy or shelter dog?

My boyfriend and I have been thinking about dogs we'd like to get in the future. And while it's still more than a year away before we're living together and ready for the commitment of a dog, I like to be prepared and start thinking early on.

Now, we (mostly I) was thinking of a Greyhound for our first dog. I've heard they're good apartment dogs, which is mostly likely where our first home would be and because I don't like small dogs or excessive exercise, I figured everyone wins with a Greyhound. I haven't done extensive research on the breed yet, so feel free to point out things or share personal stories and experiences.

Here's where the real question comes in though; do we get an adult dog from a shelter or from a breeder as a puppy?

I personally want a shelter dog. I figured retired racers would already be fairly well trained and you'd be able to tell their personalities better. And because this would be my first dog, I feel as if an adult might be more forgiving than a puppy if I make mistakes.

However, my boyfriend is leery of a shelter dog because he's had nothing, but bad experiences with them. I keep telling him it's not the shelters fault that a bad dog was chosen or that the effort wasn't put in to make the dog more well-behaved, but he's pretty stuck in his way. He insists that a puppy would be better because we can mold it more to our liking. He does have a point, but I'm still unsure. I'm afraid we wont have the energy to watch a puppy and train it right away.

So basically my question is, which do you think is better? A shelter dog or a puppy? And do you have any other recommendations for low energy (read as low exercise required) apartment dogs that AREN'T small?

Update:

I should have been more specific; when I said shelter I meant a rescue. For other breeds I'd be fine with a shelter, but I've noticed there seem to be quite a bit of rescues for Greyhounds and I do realize that a rescue would be a better option.

12 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 7
    8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Outside of racing circles, Greyhounds are not common as a breed. So finding a puppy, will be hard, not a popular breed as far as AKC registrations. Not impossible to find - but in hard economic times, more difficult than pre-2009. You'd have to check with the national club's website for referral to reputable breeders.

    You do NOT adopt a Greyhound from a local dog shelter. You get the retired racers from specific greyhound rescue groups around the country (that save them for otherwise automatic euthanasia from FL race tracks, once their racing careers end). Fostered & rescue group dogs are usually far better as pets, than the average shelter dog. Far more work & vet care has been put into them, as well as evaluation.

    Greyhounds are laid-back indoors & are usually very quiet so they can make good apartment dogs. They are active dogs outdoors (can make good running companions) & will chase anything that moves - including blowing trash, so you need a correct greyhound collar they cannot pull or back out of and should not be turned loose (off lead) other than in a fenced area. They have an easy care coat, & are a mind mannered dog. A similar but smaller breed, are whippets.

    Source(s): 29 yrs in dogs; 15 yrs = K9 rescue
  • ?
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    I have never met a Greyhound that wasn't a wonderful dog! We see quite a few at the animal hospital where I work in Georgia, since we are right next to Florida.

    Greyhounds are docile, walk well on lead, and you can do just about anything with them during a vet exam. They are real couch potatoes and don't require lots of exercise, which seems crazy.

    Working with a puppy will require a lot more of your time.

    In the end, the two of you need to agree, or you don't do anything. And don't get all mad or upset if he doesn't want the same thing you do. At the same time, don't agree to anything you really don't want, either. Be honest.

    Be sure to check into the expense of owning a puppy. You'll need an exam every 3 weeks with boosters, plus deworming, heartworm and flea meds. Then there will be the spay or neuter. Make sure you can handle all that so the dog you end up with can have the best of care.

  • 8 years ago

    Like you mentioned the retired racers, try them. Convince your boyfriend to join you on a visit to the shelter. Help him have a good experience with the ol' retirees.

    You sure you want a greyhound if you want a low exercise dog? They need a good bit of exercise, especially the retired racers, they love to run.

    Most the large dogs that don't require a lot of walking, need a hell of a lot of mental stimulation or a job. IE herding, pulling.

    If you've never had a puppy, you may want to buy some books about puppies. Its a whole different story than that of an adult dog.

    Also, I don't think many apartments allow for dogs over 20 pounds without an additional cost for rent. Make sure your landlord is cool with large dogs.

  • 8 years ago

    I would suggest a shelter dog, most of my dog's have been shelter dog's.Although in did raise 1 puppy, My Grand father told me when I got the puppy, that it take about 4 yrs to train a puppy, which I found to be true. On the other hand , shelter dogs usually have some minor issues you may have to deal with I usually only had to train a shelter dog for maybe a year.Some people think shelter dog's are defective, they are not and puppy are cute and adopt out easily. but a shelter dog is harder. in my opinion a shelter dog would be better for an a apartment than a puppy plus you would be giving a loving dog a 2nd chance. Go with the shelter dog! P.S. greyhounds still require a lot of exercise to keep them heathy!

    Source(s): Been down that road before
  • 8 years ago

    I think in your case a shelter dog would be best because its personality is already formed. Then also some shelters have puppies also. At least they may be young dogs. My husband who loves dogs also wanted a puppy because he said dogs don't live many years and he wanted to spend as much time with a dog he loved. I do understand what he means. Greyhounds are very nice dogs and I think its a good choice.

  • 8 years ago

    For apartment living, it's tricky to try and raise a puppy.

    First, with young puppies, you aren't supposed to take them out into public areas until they have completed their series of shots. And with apartments, you seldom get your own lawn.

    So you either greatly hinder your housebreaking process by not letting the pup out and using those ridiculous "pee pads", or you risk a fatal infection by taking the pup outside.

    Then there's the barking and whining issue that comes with nearly all pups. While they're learning to be quiet, your neighbours will begin to resent you.

    I too have heard excellent things about retired racing greyhounds. They typically go through rescues opposed to shelters. And what this tends to mean is that these dogs are placed in homes with a family or other dogs. During this time the dog is given very basic training on proper "house life" as well as evaluated for their temperament and behaviour. These foster homes can then give you a better picture as to "who" the dog is.

  • 7 years ago

    Wait, you want to get a dog, but you dont want to walk it...

    Just dont bother, a greyhound needs miles everyday, it would go crazy in a apartment all day, it would be like being back at the shelter, a quick 10 minute walk is not enough.

    If you do get one and dont walk it enough then shame on you!

  • 8 years ago

    Do you have $2500 to spend on a puppy? $1000 for the initial purchase plus items for the dog. $500 for early vet care plus spay/neuter. Then it's always a good idea to have at least $1000 saved up for emergency care. If you have the finances by all means go for it. Keep in mind one or both of you in some combination will need to be home 24/7 the first week or so.

  • 8 years ago

    go to http://animal.discovery.com/breed-selector/dog-bre... its a quiz that will match a dog type for you and then you can learn more about the dog breed on this site

    Off the track greyhounds that are retired, yes they have already gone to a foster home and are trained, they might be like a puppy sometimes, since they were track dogs, they never heard sounds like a toilet. Too find a good one go to http://www.petfinder.com/

    it will help you a lot!

    puppy's are sometimes difficult and adopting is less expensive to obtain the dog.

    hope this helps!

  • 8 years ago

    it would be better to get a shelter dog. like Borderline Collie said, you need to train the puppy, which would take a while. you will need to get shots and that stuff, willl will cost more money. by getting a shelter dog, you are saving a dogs life, and sometimes the dog already has their shots and is sometimes trained.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.